Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
6 min of reading 
0 comments 
Proposal Under Discussion in the Senate Provides for Advance of 10% of Inheritance to Caregiving Child at the Start of Probate and May Change Succession Rules.
In 2023 and 2024, the commission of legal experts established by the Federal Senate presented proposals for updating the Brazilian Civil Code, including relevant changes to succession rules. Among the points debated is the possibility of formally recognizing, in the probate process, the child who has demonstrably provided continuous and relevant care to parents, with financial implications for the share. One of the formulations discussed provides for the possibility of early allocation of up to 10% of the estate to this caregiving heir, right at the start of the probate, as a form of compensation.
It is essential to clarify that this is a proposal under legislative debate, not a rule already in force. The current Civil Code, in its provisions on legitimate succession, does not provide for an automatic percentage of inheritance for the caregiving child. What exists today are specific judicial mechanisms, such as the recognition of proven expenses, eventual compensation for services rendered, or agreements between heirs. The proposal under discussion seeks to provide legal predictability to a social situation that is increasingly frequent: children who take on, for years, the exclusive responsibility for caring for elderly, sick, or dependent parents.
Legal Context of Succession and the Gap Regarding Family Care
The current Civil Code establishes that, in legitimate succession, descendants inherit in equal shares, respecting the legitimate portion. Half of the deceased’s estate constitutes the legitimate portion, which is mandatorily designated for necessary heirs, such as children and spouses. The other half may be freely disposed of by will.
-
The noise law will no longer be in effect at 10 PM starting in June with a new rule valid during the 2026 World Cup.
-
The Chamber opens a debate on driver’s licenses at 16 years old as part of a reform that includes around 270 proposals to change the Brazilian Traffic Code and may redesign rules for licensing, enforcement, and circulation in the country.
-
The new Civil Code could revolutionize marriages in Brazil with “express divorce” and changes that could exclude spouses from inheritance.
-
Banco do Brasil sues famous influencer for million-dollar debt and intensifies debate on delinquency, risks of seizure, and direct impact on Gkay’s credibility.
Today, if one of the children takes care of the parents alone for years, including daily dedication, medical attendance, financial management, and restriction of their own professional life, this circumstance does not automatically alter the equal division of the inheritance. For compensation to occur, specific expenses need to be proven or a legal action must be initiated seeking indemnity for unjust enrichment or reimbursement of expenses.
The legal gap generates frequent conflicts. Brazilian courts have already analyzed cases in which caregiving children sought financial compensation for years of exclusive dedication, but the decisions vary according to documentary evidence, formal contracts, or demonstration of direct expenses. There is currently no objective rule that determines a fixed percentage for this type of situation.
The proposal discussed in the reform of the Civil Code arises precisely in this context of increasing judicialization of family disputes involving probates.
How the Advance of Up to 10% at the Start of Probate Would Work
The formulation presented by the commission of legal experts provides that, with proof of continuous and relevant care, the caregiving child may receive, at the start of the probate, up to 10% of the estate as compensation. This percentage does not overlap with the legitimate portion nor alters the status of necessary heir. It is a compensatory mechanism.
Technically, probate is the procedure that identifies the assets left by the deceased, establishes debts, defines the value of the estate, and organizes the distribution among heirs. The early payment of a compensatory portion at the start of probate would mean recognizing the caregiver’s right upfront, before the final division of assets.
The grant would not be automatic. The proposal conditions the measure on proving effective, continuous, and relevant care. This involves the analysis of evidence such as medical records, testimonies, expense records, documents indicating exclusive dedication, or substantial reduction of professional activity for caregiving.
The percentage of up to 10% functions as a cap, not as a mandatory value. The judge may set a lower percentage, depending on the circumstances of the specific case and the extent of the estate.
It is important to differentiate individual patrimonial capacity from national production or macroeconomic impact. This is a measure of a private nature, applied on a case-by-case basis in the probate of each family, without direct impact on public finances or taxation.
Social and Economic Basis of the Proposal: Aging and Informal Care
The legislative debate occurs in a specific demographic context. Brazil is experiencing rapid population aging. Data from IBGE indicate significant growth of the population over 60 years in recent decades. Consequently, there is an increasing demand for long-term care, especially in cases of chronic diseases, physical limitations, and functional dependence.
A large part of this care is informal, provided by family members, especially children and, historically, women. In many cases, the caregiver reduces working hours, abandons their career, or incurs direct costs with medications, transportation, and home adaptations.
Without a clear legal provision, financial recognition of this care hinges on complex legal disputes. The proposal for early allocation of a percentage in probate seeks to create an objective mechanism to prevent the caregiving child from being treated exactly the same as heirs who did not participate in the caregiving, without any consideration for the effort expended.
From a family economic perspective, probate often involves real estate, financial investments, and ownership stakes. An advance of 10% could represent a significant amount, depending on the total estate. In high-value inheritances, the measure may significantly alter the negotiation dynamics among heirs.
Procedural Technicalities and Proof Criteria
One of the main challenges of the proposal lies in the objective definition of what constitutes “continuous and relevant care.” Civil law requires clear criteria to avoid excessive subjectivity.
In technical terms, the judge would need to evaluate factors such as the duration of care, intensity, exclusivity, economic impact on the caregiver’s life, and any tacit agreement from the deceased. The lack of a formal service contract may hinder proof.
It is also necessary to distinguish affectionate care from care with measurable patrimonial repercussions. Simple family coexistence does not generate compensatory rights. The proposal tends to require demonstration of substantial dedication that produced concrete benefits for the deceased, reducing the need for hiring professional caregivers or institutions.
Another sensitive point is the balance among heirs. The advance of 10% must respect the legitimate portion and cannot compromise the minimum rights of other necessary heirs. The text under discussion seeks to reconcile compensation with succession equality, avoiding the interpretation that the measure grants absolute privilege.
Succession Impacts, Potential Conflicts, and Future Implications
If the proposal is approved and incorporated into the Civil Code, there will be a structural change in the logic of succession in Brazil. The traditional rule of equal division among descendants would coexist with an explicit compensatory mechanism.
From a practical standpoint, an initial increase in evidentiary disputes is foreseeable, especially regarding the extent of care provided. However, the existence of a legal provision may also reduce litigation by offering clear criteria for extrajudicial agreements.
The measure aligns with the international trend of valuing informal care. In various countries, legal systems recognize compensation for heirs who assume extraordinary burdens in assisting elderly relatives.
However, there are criticisms. Some legal experts point to the risk of commercialization of family relationships and potential encouragement of premature conflicts. Others argue that compensation can already be sought through indemnity actions, without the need for legislative change.
From Moral Duty to Possible Succession Right
It is crucial to reiterate that, to date, there is no law in force determining an automatic payment of 10% of the inheritance to the caregiving child. The discussion integrates a broader process of modernizing the Civil Code, which also encompasses themes such as digital succession, protection of vulnerable individuals, and new family structures.
If approved, the change will represent one of the most significant alterations in the legal engineering of Brazilian succession in recent decades. By formally recognizing the economic value of family caregiving, the legislator may redefine the balance between succession equality and compensatory justice.
The ongoing debate reveals that inheritance is no longer merely a patrimonial issue. It begins to incorporate a social dimension linked to population aging, the burden on caregivers, and the redistribution of responsibilities within families. The legislative outcome will determine whether caregiving will cease to be solely a moral duty to also acquire structured legal recognition at the time of sharing.
Seja o primeiro a reagir!