Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
5 min of reading 
0 comments 
Long Incarceration, Million-Dollar Settlement and Official Apology Stir Debate About Judicial Failures in the United States.
At 68 years old, American Ronnie Wallace Long, a Black man wrongfully convicted in 1976 for a rape that Justice later recognized he did not commit, received a public apology and settled for US$ 25 million, about R$ 130 million, after spending 44 years in prison in North Carolina.
The settlement involves the city of Concord and the state investigative agency, following decades of questioning the conduct of the original investigation and structural failures pointed out by legal and civil rights organizations.
Million-Dollar Settlement and Public Apologies
The amount of US$ 25 million results from a civil action for civil rights violations filed by Long in federal court.
-
Long before we imagined: the first humans were already doing heavy mining in South Africa over 200,000 years ago!
-
Few people know, but the most used pencil in the world is manufactured using extreme heat, the extraction of graphite from deposits millions of years old, a mixture of clay and water, followed by extrusion under nearly 10 tons of pressure and drying in an oven at 120 degrees.
-
European country ‘darling of Brazilians’ will need 1.3 million workers by 2030 to avoid collapse, and immigration has become the only way to save the economy.
-
The government allows the new ID to be requested on a mobile phone and delivered at home.
The lawsuit stated that authorities in Concord and the State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) had concealed evidence, influenced jury selection, and contributed to a conviction that kept Long incarcerated for more than four decades, according to documents presented by the defense.
In an official statement, the city of Concord announced the payment of US$ 22 million and issued a formal apology directed to Long, his family, and the community.
The text acknowledges “serious errors in judgment” and “deliberate misconduct” by former municipal employees.
The municipality further stated that Long “served 44 years, 3 months, and 17 days in prison for a crime he did not commit” and claimed that the settlement seeks to take institutional responsibility for the identified failures.
The US$ 3 million remaining had already been agreed upon in 2023 with the state investigative agency, totaling US$ 25 million.
Organizations specializing in exonerations classify the amount as the largest settlement for wrongful incarceration ever reached in North Carolina.
Official Pardon and State Compensation
Before this outcome, Long had received US$ 750,000, the maximum amount stipulated by state law for victims of wrongful convictions.
The payment was authorized after the granting of a “pardon of innocence” by Governor Roy Cooper in December 2020, a document that officially reaffirms the beneficiary’s innocence.
According to the Duke University Wrongful Convictions Clinic, which represented him in the criminal case and the civil action, only two exonerees in the United States had been imprisoned longer than Long before having their convictions overturned.
1976 Conviction and Failures Pointed Out in Jury
The conviction occurred in 1976, after a jury composed exclusively of white people found Long guilty of the rape and burglary of a white widow in Concord.
Court records and local reports indicate that dozens of potential Black jurors were dismissed during jury selection, resulting in a racially unbalanced panel.
The accusation was primarily based on the victim’s identification, conducted in the courtroom under conditions later described by experts as highly suggestive for mistaken identification.
Long’s attorneys later discovered that over 40 fingerprints collected at the crime scene did not match those of the accused at the time.
Samples of semen, fibers, and other traces also did not establish a link between Long and the attack, according to reports presented in later stages of the case.
These materials were not shown to the jury at the time.
Documented Omissions and Case Review
Documents released at various stages of the litigation indicate that agents responsible for the investigation omitted relevant information and provided testimonies later classified as inconsistent with the content of police files.
Despite questions raised by civil rights organizations, state court decisions upheld the conviction for decades.
The situation changed in 2015, when the Duke University Wrongful Convictions Clinic took over the case.
The team reviewed the records and reported violations of the right to due process, including suppression of potentially favorable evidence for the defendant.
In 2020, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, in an expanded session, concluded that Long’s constitutional rights had been violated.
The court returned the case to the lower court for reconsideration of the issue of innocence, an understanding that paved the way for the end of the conviction.
Release from Prison and Formal Exoneration
In August 2020, after 44 years incarcerated, Long left Albemarle prison while state authorities evaluated the implementation of the federal decision.
He was 65 years old upon his release.
Four months later, in December 2020, Governor Roy Cooper granted the “pardon of innocence,” an act that formalized the exoneration and allowed access to compensation provided for by state law.
With the pardon established and the administrative compensation completed, the defense filed a civil rights action in 2021 listing more than a dozen defendants, including municipalities, former police officers, public officials, and SBI agents.
The document described suppression of evidence, failures in conducting the investigation, and obstacles to Long’s access to the courts.
Judicial Negotiations and Public Repercussions
Subsequent decisions by federal courts rejected motions for dismissal presented by some defendants, allowing the process to advance.
In 2023, the group linked to the state investigative agency agreed to pay US$ 3 million.
In early 2024, the city of Concord finalized the payment of US$ 22 million and issued the formal apology, ending the litigation.
Criminal justice researchers state that the case exemplifies recurring problems observed in wrongful conviction processes in the United States, such as unreliable identification methods, racially unbalanced juries, failure to disclose favorable evidence to the defense, and institutional delays in reviewing cases with new elements.
In statements released after the settlement, Long stated that no financial amount can compensate for the time he was incarcerated, marked by family events he could not attend.
The legal team considers the outcome significant for the formal recognition of the responsibility of the involved institutions, according to a note released by the attorneys.
So far, there are no consolidated records in public sources of individual criminal or disciplinary accountability of agents linked to the original investigation, beyond the civil liability recognition provided for in the settlement.
Given the factors gathered over more than four decades, what kind of structural changes in the justice system do you consider necessary to reduce the possibility of new wrongful convictions?
-
-
3 pessoas reagiram a isso.