Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
6 min of reading 
0 comments 
The Charging of a Deposit Above Three Months’ Rent Is Illegal and Can Give Right to Refund. Understand How to Identify the Excess Amount in the Contract, Calculate the Difference, and Request a Refund with Monetary Correction.
Paid more than 3 months’ rent as a deposit? See how to check the contract, calculate the excess, and request a refund with correction.
The requirement for cash deposit above three months’ rent contradicts the Tenancy Law and can be contested with documentary evidence.
The article 38 states that if the deposit in cash is chosen, the maximum amount is three months’ rent and must be deposited in a linked savings account, with the earnings reverted to the tenant at the end of the lease, in the absence of debts.
-
The Chamber opens a debate on driver’s licenses at 16 years old as part of a reform that includes around 270 proposals to change the Brazilian Traffic Code and may redesign rules for licensing, enforcement, and circulation in the country.
-
The new Civil Code could revolutionize marriages in Brazil with “express divorce” and changes that could exclude spouses from inheritance.
-
Banco do Brasil sues famous influencer for million-dollar debt and intensifies debate on delinquency, risks of seizure, and direct impact on Gkay’s credibility.
-
The Senate approves a bill that criminalizes misogyny, hatred, or aversion towards women, and includes the crime in the Racism Law with a penalty of up to 5 years.
If there is a charge above the cap, the excess is undue and can be refunded with the same adjustment as the savings account.
What the Law Determines for Cash Deposits
The legal rule is objective and does not allow for expansion through market practices.
Whenever the guarantee is a cash deposit, the amount must be invested in a savings account linked to the contract, in the name of the tenant, with transparency about the opening date, anniversary, and balance.
At the end of the lease, the amount returned must reflect exactly what is shown in the statements, provided there are no amounts to offset for default or duly proven repairs.
How to Identify Charges Above the Cap in Your Contract
The first step is to read the contract.
In general, it outlines the type of guarantee chosen, the amount of the deposit, and the way it is applied.
When the instrument records four months’ rent or includes formulas that, in practice, exceed the reference of three months, there is noncompliance.
Even if the contract is silent, payment receipts and bank statements are sufficient to demonstrate that the requirement exceeded the limit.
In any scenario, the verification is done through direct comparison between what was requested and what the law permits.
Mandatory Deposit in Linked Savings Account and the Trail of Evidence
The linked savings account serves two purposes: it preserves the purchasing power of the deposited value and creates a audit trail through the statements.
These statements show the progress month by month, the anniversary date, and the interest credits.
If the entire amount was correctly deposited, the refund of the excess will accompany the proportional remuneration of the savings from the date of deposit.
If the deposit was not made, the lack of accountability does not harm the tenant: the recomposition should follow the remuneration that the savings would have produced during the same period, based on payment receipts and recorded dates.
When to Request the Refund and How to Organize the Documentation
The most common time to request regularization is at the end of the lease, when debts, damages are checked, and keys are handed over.
However, nothing prevents the tenant from requesting adjustment to the legal cap and the proof of the linked savings account during the contract’s duration, especially upon identifying irregularities while reviewing the contract or gathering documents for tax declaration.
In both cases, the evidentiary basis is simple: lease contract indicating the guarantee and the agreed amount, deposit receipts, move-in inspection record, and documents proving payment compliance.
Ways to Solution: Administrative, Consumer, and Justice
When the real estate agency or the owner recognizes the undue charge and provides the documents, the solution is usually administrative: the excess over three months of rent is determined, the remuneration of the savings until the date of refund is calculated, and payment is made.
If discrepancies persist or essential documents are lacking, it is advisable to send a formal notice requesting adjustment of the amount and presentation of the statements of the linked savings account.
If there is no agreement, the consumer can file a complaint with a consumer protection agency, which will attempt conciliation and require documentation to be gathered.
As a last resort, the judicial route remains available, with a request for document presentation and refund of what was overpaid, plus applicable remuneration.
How to Calculate the Excess and the Correction
The calculation does not require complex expertise.
In contracts that define the deposit as multiples of rent, identify the amount equivalent to three months’ rent and compare it with what was charged.
The difference is the excess to be refunded.
Next, check in the savings statements the deposit date and the interest credits for each month.
The remuneration of the savings account is automatically applied by the bank according to the rules in effect for savings, which vary according to the Selic rate and the TR of each period.
The final amount to be refunded corresponds to the balance resulting from this mechanics.
If there are no statements due to the depositary’s failure, the parameter remains that of the savings, based on the dates and amounts documented by the tenant.
Attention to Fractured Deposits and Rent Adjustments
Some contracts provide for fractured deposits, either through initial installment or addendums that increase the guarantee over the duration.
In these cases, verification should consider the dates of each contribution, as the savings account remunerates based on the “anniversary” of the deposit.
Still, the total amount of deposits cannot exceed three months’ rent valid at the time of the requirement.
Annual rent adjustments do not, by themselves, authorize raising the deposit above the cap unless there is a contractual provision that remains within the limit and that the deposits are correctly made into the linked savings account.
Whenever the total exceeds the limit, the excess portion is undue and subject to refund, with earnings from each deposit date.
Caution with Disguised Charges Under the Guarantee Label
There is a recurring confusion between deposits and initial charges such as intermediation fees or administrative expenses.
The Tenancy Law does not allow the use of these items to bypass the cap of three months’ rent.
If the sum of charges “as a guarantee” exceeds the limit, even if distributed under different names, the analysis of the invoices, receipts, and the flow of money to the linked savings account can reveal the diversion.
The absence of a deposit in savings in the name and benefit of the contract indicates that the legal rule was not observed.
In Case of Impasse, the Parameter Is Objective
When dialogue fails, the controversy tends to be resolved with the documentary demonstration of the excess and the absence of valid contractual justification.
Since the reference is objective — cap of three months for cash deposits, mandatory deposit in linked savings account, and refund with the interest from that application — mediation or judicial decisions tend to follow these benchmarks.
For a safer approach, it is advisable to formally document requests and keep copies of all documents.
Factual Note and Practical Guidance
There is no unique and standardized public procedure to return the excess during the contract’s duration; in practice, the discussion usually occurs at the end of the lease when accounts are settled, and the property is returned.
In case of doubt, it is worth formalizing the notice and seeking legal advice based on the contract, the deposit receipts, and the statements from the linked savings account, when available.
Upon reviewing the contract and the receipts, did you identify amounts “as a guarantee” that exceed three months’ rent and already requested the administrator for the linked savings account statements to accurately calculate what should be refunded?
-
-
-
-
9 pessoas reagiram a isso.