Rule of Law 14.661/2023 Dispenses With Civil Process When There Is a Final Criminal Conviction and Directly Affects Participation in Inheritance
The criminal conviction that has become final for intentional homicide, including femicide, has led to automatic exclusion of the heir for indignity in the Civil Code, after the Law 14.661/2023.
In practice, this eliminates the need for a civil action to discuss indignity when the criminal justice system has already concluded the judgment with a definitive decision.
What Happened and Why This Caught Attention
The Family and Succession Court of Guarapuava (PR) dismissed a civil case that sought to declare the indignity of a man convicted of femicide against his own wife.
-
With the arrival of Law 11.788, internships are now recognized as professional experience.
-
The Brazilian Civil Code states that a property owner has the right to cut the roots of a neighbor’s tree that invade their land, as long as it does not harm the tree itself. The owner must notify the neighbor before taking such action.
-
Engineer is sentenced to repay R$ 148 thousand after holding public positions in three municipalities in Rondônia with incompatible schedules, and the decision is upheld by the Court of Justice.
-
Chamber approves project that creates mandatory Life Insurance for police officers, firefighters, guards, and traffic agents.
The judge Aneíza Vanêssa Costa do Nascimento did not analyze the merits of the civil request because the criminal conviction had already become final.
The case involves the death of the lawyer Tatiane Spitzner, which occurred in 2018, attributed to her husband.
Who Can Be Excluded From the Inheritance and What the Law Says When Applicable
The change incorporated into the Civil Code provides for automatic exclusion for indignity when there is a final criminal conviction for intentional homicide against the person whose inheritance is in discussion.
Femicide falls under this classification as it is considered intentional homicide within the circumstances of the crime.
Even when the death occurred before the regulation, the rule can be applied if the final judgment happens during the validity of Law 14.661/2023.
How Final Judgment Works and Why It Matters in the Process
A final judgment means that the conviction has become definitive, with no possibility of new appeals that change the outcome.
With the definitive conviction in the criminal sphere, the discussion about guilt ceases to be the central point in the civil sphere because criminal responsibility has already been acknowledged.
In this situation, the law begins to operate with a direct effect on succession, leading to automatic exclusion of the heir.
Why the Civil Action Was Dismissed Even Though It Was Filed Earlier
The civil action was filed in 2021 by the victim’s parents when the criminal case was still ongoing.
The final judgment of the conviction for femicide occurred in the last month of June, and the defendant himself requested the recognition of the loss of procedural interest based on Law 14.661/2023.
The parents argued for the application of the legislation in force at the time of the murder, but the decision applied the rule from 2023 and recognized the automatic exclusion from inheritance.
Costs and Fees: What Was Decided Despite the End of the Process
Even with the case dismissed, the man was ordered to pay court costs and attorney’s fees.
The justification was that he caused the filing of the civil action, as the process was initiated before the regulation that established automatic exclusion.
The case is being processed under judicial secrecy, and the lawyers Rogéria Dotti and Diana Geara were involved in the case.
The decision reinforces that a definitive conviction for femicide can directly impact the right to inherit, with automatic application of the indignity rule.
It also indicates that civil processes initiated before the legal change can be concluded after the final judgment, maintaining, when applicable, the charging of costs and fees from the party that initiated the action.

-
Uma pessoa reagiu a isso.