A study submitted to Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court estimates the effects of a possible mass shift of workers to contracts with their own companies. The calculations include tax revenue, social security and labor rights, but represent hypothetical scenarios, not losses already recorded.
A change in how workers are hired could have an impact of up to R$200.4 billion a year on the Brazilian economy and prompt more than 1 million employees with formal labor contracts to shift to the legal-entity (PJ) system.
The estimate appears in a technical study commissioned by the Brazilian Bar Association’s São Paulo chapter (OAB-SP) and submitted to Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (STF) on November 18, 2026.
The figures stand out for their scale, but also for a less obvious detail: some of the money is not tax revenue. The calculation includes social security contributions, deposits into Brazil’s FGTS severance fund and portions of labor rights that would no longer be paid under the simulated contracts.
-
Tax reform could push prices higher as early as 2027, finance minister admits; Central Bank has not factored potential shock into forecasts, and Senate questions 11.3% rate
-
Avelloz to Begin Assembling AZ170 Bravo in December with Plans for 500 Jobs in Manaus
-
Gasoline Prices Drop in Rio Grande do Norte: Guamaré Refinery Lowers Gasoline A to R$3.66 per Liter, Third Consecutive Reduction, Totaling R$0.48 Over Three Weeks, While Diesel Prices Also Decrease
-
Tomato prices jump 19.6% as October inflation divides Brazil: costs rise 0.26% for the poorest households but fall 0.07% for the richest, Ipea study finds
The document comes amid the STF’s debate over hiring workers through their own legal entities, which could establish nationwide rules for hiring independent contractors and companies.

More than 1 million workers could leave formal employment to work through their own companies
The technical study was prepared by economists Nelson Marconi and Marco Capraro Brancher, using data from the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE)’s Continuous National Household Sample Survey (Pnad Contínua).
The study found that in 2025, Brazil had approximately 415,800 employees with formal labor contracts earning more than twice the INSS social security contribution ceiling. These high-income professionals are at the center of the simulations.
That same year, another 310,100 professionals in this income bracket were self-employed and had a CNPJ, Brazil’s corporate taxpayer ID. The second group’s share of the population analyzed rose from about 22% between 2012 and 2019 to 43% in 2025.
But the researchers identified the potential for even greater growth.
The calculations suggest companies could offer higher pay to employees earning just below the high-income threshold, making it financially advantageous to hire them through their own companies.
This additional group includes 666,800 workers employed under the CLT, Brazil’s labor code, earning between R$10,553 and R$16,911 a month, in June 2026 prices.
Together with the 415,800 higher-income employees, they make up a pool of approximately 1.08 million people who could shift under the broadest scenario.
This does not mean that all of them will leave formal employment under the CLT, Brazil’s labor code. The figure represents a scenario used to calculate the potential economic impacts of the change.
Where does the R$200 billion figure come from, and how much tax revenue could be lost?
The difference between working under a formal labor contract and providing services through a company goes beyond the contract itself. It also changes how taxes, contributions and labor benefits are calculated.
Under employment governed by the CLT, Brazil’s labor code, employers must pay labor charges and meet obligations such as making deposits into Brazil’s FGTS severance fund and providing vacation pay and a 13th-month salary.
When hiring workers through their own legal entities, taxation follows the rules that apply to the service provider’s company, while benefits typically associated with an employment relationship are not automatically guaranteed.
That difference is the source of the billion-real estimate.
In a scenario in which all 1.08 million workers switch, the study estimates an annual impact of R$200.4 billion. However, that total includes amounts that are not government tax revenue.
When the researchers exclude vacation pay, 13th-month salaries and provisions for termination penalties, the estimated amount falls to R$139.9 billion a year.
Even that second figure should not be interpreted entirely as money that would no longer flow into public coffers, since it includes deposits into Brazil’s FGTS severance fund, which go into workers’ accounts.
Brazil’s social security system is among the components most affected. In the broader scenario, the simulation estimates a net reduction of R$71.3 billion a year in social security contributions.
The figures are projections based on the tax rules considered by the authors and 2025 labor-market data. They do not represent losses actually recorded in 2026.
Why might companies and professionals see hiring workers through their own legal entities as advantageous?
Interest in the legal-entity (PJ) system may stem from a simple combination: companies could reduce costs, while professionals could receive higher monthly pay.
For workers earning close to the high-income threshold, economists calculated that companies could offer an average 24.4% increase in gross pay and still save money by changing the contract arrangement.
The estimate assumes average savings of R$5,288 per worker per month for the company, under the conditions used in the simulation.
But receiving a higher monthly amount does not necessarily mean coming out ahead financially over the course of the year.
A professional hired as a PJ needs to account for taxes on their company and set aside funds for periods without work, paid time off and social security protection.
By contrast, employees under the CLT have legally guaranteed rights, including paid vacation with a constitutional bonus, a 13th-month salary and deposits into Brazil’s FGTS severance fund.

Hiring workers through their own legal entities can be legitimate when they provide genuinely independent services. The legal issue arises when a business contract is used to conceal a relationship that has the characteristics of employment.
OAB-SP says the economic incentives created by differences between the systems could encourage widespread migration and reduce funding for social protection mechanisms.
What will Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court decide about hiring workers through their own legal entities?
The debate centers on General Repercussion Theme 1,389, which is being overseen by Justice Gilmar Mendes at Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (STF).
The case examines whether hiring independent contractors and legal entities under the legal-entity (PJ) system to provide services is valid. It also addresses which court should hear allegations of contract fraud and who is responsible for presenting the evidence.
The ruling could establish standards to be followed in similar cases across the country.
In 2025, the STF ordered a nationwide suspension of cases related to the issue. In June 2026, it partially modified the suspension, allowing cases to proceed in lower labor courts, but requiring them to pause after rulings by regional labor courts while the Supreme Court’s decision is pending.
The submission by OAB-SP seeks to add an economic dimension to the debate, focusing in particular on the potential effects of high-income workers moving to contracts under the legal-entity (PJ) system.
The study also presents less extreme scenarios. If half of the workers included in the expanded scenario were to move, for example, the estimated annual losses would be approximately R$74 billion to R$100 billion, depending on the other assumptions used.
As of the latest case-status update reviewed, the STF had not yet established a definitive legal test for Theme 1,389.
The ruling is expected to clarify the legal treatment of the arrangements at issue, while the figures presented by OAB-SP remain estimates of possible economic consequences, contingent on how companies and workers respond.
