Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
3 min of reading 
0 comments 
Raphaël Glucksmann’s Proposal Reignites Debate on U.S. Influence in the Global Arena and Divides Opinions Among French and American Politicians
French Eurodeputy Raphaël Glucksmann, leader of the Place Publique party, suggested that the United States return the Statue of Liberty to France, arguing that the country no longer represents the values that inspired the donation of the monument in 1886. During a party convention, Glucksmann criticized the external and internal policies of the U.S. government, citing the war in Ukraine, cuts in scientific investments, and the current political polarization in the U.S. as examples of a departure from the ideals of liberty and democracy that the statue symbolizes. The statement generated significant international repercussions and reignited debates about the monument’s role in global politics, as well as highlighting tensions between different political spectrums in Europe and the United States.
The proposal, which started as a symbolic critique, quickly gained international attention. According to The Guardian, Glucksmann argued that the United States “disregards the fundamental principles of freedom” and that, in this context, the monument would be better located on French territory. “If the values for which this statue was offered are no longer respected, then perhaps we should bring it back,” the Eurodeputy declared.
U.S. Reaction and Public Opinion
The suggestion was not well-received by the White House, which responded immediately to the statement. Government spokesperson Karoline Leavitt mocked the idea and reminded that the French “should be thankful to the U.S. for their liberation in World War II.” The response reinforced the position that the statue, one of the most recognized icons of the United States, definitely belongs to the country and that its return has never been considered. The official U.S. stance was widely reported in the international media, highlighting the controversy generated by the French Eurodeputy’s statement.
-
‘Mini Cataratas do Iguaçu’ in SC will receive 11 cabins amidst nature and a new deck after an investment of over R$ 1 million.
-
Electric station costing R$ 171,000 could become passive income in Brazil: a 60 kW fast charger promises to earn up to R$ 21,600 per month, but it depends on a busy location, cheap energy, and electric drivers in need of urgent recharging in the city.
-
A junkyard has turned into an open-air airplane museum, made from retired fuselages and even doing business with Embraer, where you can enter the aircraft, pretend to start the engines, and take an entire plane home for around 100,000 reais.
-
With 4 floors and over 1,100 m², this $15 million floating mansion has 5 suites, 7 bathrooms, a pool, solar energy, and technology used in ships from the oil industry.
Glucksmann’s proposal also generated divergent reactions in France. While leftist politicians viewed the comment as a legitimate criticism of the U.S. government, parties more aligned with the center and right considered the suggestion exaggerated and populist. The newspaper Le Monde noted that the French government itself has no intention to reclaim the statue, treating the Eurodeputy’s remarks more as a provocation than a real demand. Meanwhile, members of the Rassemblement National, a far-right party led by Marine Le Pen, took advantage of the controversy to criticize U.S. global influence and advocate for greater independence for France in international decisions.
History and Symbolism of the Statue of Liberty
The Statue of Liberty, officially called La Liberté éclairant le monde (Liberty Enlightening the World), was a gift from France to the United States to celebrate American independence and strengthen the ties between the two nations. The monument was designed by sculptor Frédéric Auguste Bartholdi, and its internal structure was developed by renowned engineer Gustave Eiffel, the same creator of the Eiffel Tower.
The statue was inaugurated on October 28, 1886, at the Port of New York, and has since become one of the greatest symbols of the U.S., representing freedom, democracy, and the reception of immigrants. For many experts, Glucksmann’s comments seek to reclaim this symbolism and question whether the United States is still an example of these ideals in the current scenario.
Be the first to react!