Portuguese 
Spanish 
4 min of reading 
0 comments 
Brazilian law allows parents to request support from adult children, but material and emotional abandonment can weaken the claim and open space for discussion about compensation in court.
A father or mother can request support from adult children when they prove financial need, but this right is not automatic and can be dismissed when there is a history of material or emotional abandonment.
The general rule is in the Civil Code, which provides for reciprocity in the obligation of support between parents and children, but the court analyzes each case based on evidence, the need of the requester, and the economic capacity of the one who could pay.
Support request depends on need and possibility
Article 1,696 of the Civil Code establishes that the right to support is reciprocal between parents and children, also reaching other ascendants according to the order provided by law.
-
A geometry book written 2,300 years ago taught Lincoln to be a lawyer, Einstein to think in physics, and Russell to understand logic, and no MBA in the world has managed to replicate this feat.
-
Woman loses house in devastating fire and now sees 35 people rebuilding her home with over 350 tires, bottles, and cans in a sustainable project designed to withstand fire.
-
At 80 years old, Mr. Vicente opens a vendorless stall every day at 7 a.m. in the countryside of Minas Gerais, leaves, and expects customers to pay on their own for what they take, and the system has been working for 7 years.
-
Beach bans umbrellas for people between 10 and 65 years old, charges a fee of R$ 59 for access, and adopts measure after an incident that required evacuation of bathers amid chaos, in Italy.
In practice, this means that an elderly, sick, or insufficiently funded parent can judicially request support from adult children, as long as they demonstrate real need and the financial capacity of the possible responsible parties.
This right, however, does not function as an automatic claim based solely on the birth certificate or the existence of a biological relationship.
Before setting support, the judge usually analyzes the binomial of need and possibility, as well as the family history that helps explain the relationship between the parties.
When the parent requesting support was present, fulfilled parental duties, and now faces a situation of vulnerability, the obligation of support can be recognized based on family solidarity.
The situation changes when evidence indicates prolonged abandonment, lack of support, severed cohabitation, and lack of participation in the children’s upbringing.
Abandonment can weaken the claim
The Civil Code also provides, in article 1,708, that the obligation of support can cease when there is unworthy behavior by the creditor towards the debtor.
In support actions filed by parents against children, this rule can be discussed when the parent failed to fulfill basic duties during the descendants’ childhood or adolescence.
The defense often uses this argument to demonstrate that there was no true family solidarity, but merely a late attempt to demand financial support after years of estrangement.
Material abandonment, failure to pay support, and emotional distancing can weigh against the one requesting support, provided these circumstances are proven in the process.
It is not enough to claim that there was family resentment or lack of cohabitation; documents, witnesses, and records from the upbringing period are essential to ensure the judicial decision’s security.
Case judged in Ceará shows the understanding of Justice
A case disclosed by the Court of Justice of Ceará shows how abandonment can influence the outcome of a child support action.
In a decision by the 16th Family Court of Fortaleza, Judge Cléber de Castro Cruz denied the request of an elderly man seeking support from his three children after evidence indicated material and emotional abandonment.
According to the TJCE, the father had not been in contact with the family since 1991 and had abandoned the children when they were 16, 12, and seven years old.
In the decision, the magistrate stated that it would not be fair or legal to allow the plaintiff to use the paternal condition only to impose obligations on the children after not acting as a father when they needed care and material assistance.
The court also reported that the man filed the action in 2011, claiming illness, advanced age, and lack of work conditions.
Although he received provisional support during part of the process, the request was denied in the end, precisely due to the evaluation of the abandonment history described in the records.
Evidence is decisive in the defense of the children
When an absent parent requests support, the defense of the children should focus on the objective reconstruction of the family history.
School records, medical documents, absence of support receipts, witnesses, old messages, and previous judicial decisions can help demonstrate the parent’s lack of involvement.
Documents showing who bore the upbringing expenses, who accompanied the school and medical life, and whether there was a real attempt at cohabitation over the years can also be relevant.
The child’s assets, high income, or acquisition of goods are not enough, in isolation, to define the support obligation.
Financial capacity can be considered, but the judge also needs to evaluate whether the request respects the logic of family solidarity or ignores a proven history of abandonment.
Therefore, cases involving absent parents require careful analysis and should not be treated as a simple dispute between those with assets and those seeking help.
The same action seeking support can reveal facts capable of weakening the request and, in certain situations, open space for discussion about civil reparation for emotional abandonment.
Be the first to react!