Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
3 min of reading 
0 comments 
Results of the 2022 DART Mission and CERN Experiments with 440 GeV Proton Beams Indicate That Metallic Asteroids May Withstand Nuclear Explosions, Maintaining the Possibility of Controlled Deflection in Extreme Planetary Defense Scenarios with Little Response Time
The first planetary defense test in space, conducted in 2022, showed that the deliberate collision of a spacecraft can alter an asteroid’s trajectory, while new CERN experiments indicate that, in extreme scenarios, nuclear deflection may be more effective than previously thought.
The DART Mission and the Direct Orbital Deflection Test
The DART mission, conducted by NASA, marked the first practical planetary defense test by sending a spacecraft to collide with an asteroid in 2022. The goal was to evaluate whether a kinetic impact could alter its trajectory.
The test was considered a success because it demonstrated that, in a hypothetical scenario of imminent collision with Earth, a direct intervention could modify the path of a large celestial body.
-
A torpedo-sized submarine robot was launched through a 600-meter hole in the “doomsday glacier” and revealed cracks melting up to 10 times faster; Icefin showed from the inside how warm water threatens Thwaites, an ice mass capable of raising sea levels by almost 70 cm.
-
The iPod is back in full force: young people are reviving Apple’s old device to escape digital distractions and control their own soundtrack.
-
For the first time in history, a submarine cable will descend to four thousand meters deep under the ice of the North Pole to ensure that the internet between Europe and Asia no longer depends on conflict zones in the Middle East.
-
A British company has installed in the middle of the ocean the world’s first floating platform that generates electricity 24 hours a day from the temperature difference between the surface and the depths of the Atlantic, without relying on wind or sun.
Scientists view this approach as more favorable than the immediate use of nuclear weapons, as the explosion could fragment the asteroid into several smaller pieces that would continue on a dangerous course.
Nuclear Deflection as a Last Scientific Resort
Despite the advantages of kinetic impact, nuclear deflection remains an emergency alternative for extreme situations. In this context, a team linked to the Proton Synchrotron at CERN conducted new research on the resistance of asteroid materials.
The study indicates that some types of space rocks, particularly those rich in metals, may be more resistant to nuclear explosions than previously imagined. This reduces the risk of uncontrolled fragmentation.
According to the researchers, understanding the composition of the asteroid is one of the most critical variables in any planetary defense mission, whether based on direct impact or controlled nuclear explosion.
Advanced Modeling and Scientific Publication
The results were detailed in a paper published in the journal Nature Communications, in which the team describes the use of advanced models to evaluate the effectiveness of nuclear deflection.
Karl-Georg Schlesinger, co-founder of OuSoCo, explained in an interview with CERN Courier that planetary defense represents a unique scientific challenge, as it is not possible to conduct real tests in advance.
According to him, the world needs to have the capability to execute a nuclear deflection mission with a high degree of confidence, even without the possibility of experimentation under real conditions, which imposes extraordinary demands on materials and physics data.
Experiments with 440 GeV Proton Beam
To address these uncertainties, the team conducted experiments at CERN’s HiRadMat facilities, in collaboration with Fireball and the University of Oxford. They fired 27 short and intense pulses of a 440 GeV proton beam.
The pulses hit a sample of the Campo del Cielo meteorite, simulating in the lab some effects of a nuclear detonation, without the need to explode a real weapon of mass destruction.
Melanie Bochmann, co-founder and co-leader of the team, stated that the material became more resistant after the impacts, with increased yield strength and self-stabilizing damping behavior.
Implications for Emergency Scenarios
The experiments indicate that, at least for metallic materials of asteroids, a nuclear device larger than previously considered could be used without causing catastrophic damage to the celestial body’s structure.
For the researchers, this is a positive finding, as it suggests that a powerful nuclear weapon could deflect an asteroid without fragmenting it into multiple smaller and equally dangerous pieces.
Bochmann explained that this possibility keeps an emergency option open for situations involving very large objects or extremely short warning times, when non-nuclear methods would be insufficient.
In such cases, current models, which assume fragmentation as a limiting factor, may need to be revised in light of the new experimental data obtained in the laboratory.
Be the first to react!