Judge Used AI to Issue Ruling Based on Non-Existent Law

Written by Fabio Lucas Carvalho

Published on 01/08/2025 at 12:37

Foto: Reprodução

Be the first to react!

A judicial decision in the United States garnered attention for containing serious errors and references to nonexistent laws and cases. The most important thing is that the text raised suspicions of being written with the help of artificial intelligence, which reignited the debate about the use of this technology in the judicial system.

A recent judicial decision caused perplexity in the state of Mississippi, in the United States. The most important thing is that the document, signed by federal judge Henry Wingate, presents serious factual errors.

Among the problems are names of nonexistent plaintiffs, incorrectly cited state laws, and even references to cases that never happened.

Confusing Order Raises Suspicions

The confusion began earlier this month when Wingate issued a temporary restraining order. Lawyers involved in the case immediately suspected that the text might have been generated by artificial intelligence.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW

Lack of Explanations Aggravates Situation

The judge has yet to comment on the case. He neither confirmed nor denied the use of artificial intelligence in drafting the decision.

The silence increases frustration among experts and lawyers. “Our lawyers have never seen anything like this,” reported an employee of the Office of the Attorney General of Mississippi.

Christina Frohock, a professor at the University of Miami School of Law, also expressed surprise. “I feel like I’m in Alice in Wonderland,” she stated.

She said she doesn’t know how to explain the source of so many errors and raised a delicate question: when the error comes from the judge, there are no clear mechanisms to demand explanations.

Debate About AI in the Judiciary Gains Momentum

Previous cases have already shown that lawyers have been punished for using AI to create petitions with false information. However, this is one of the first times a judge is accused of doing the same.

The difference, according to experts, is that there are no clear rules on how to handle this type of situation when the author of the mistake is the judge himself.

Therefore, the episode reignites the debate about the use of artificial intelligence tools in the judicial system.

Meanwhile, the question remains: was the decision really written by an AI? Perhaps we will never know.

Judge Used AI to Issue Ruling Based on Non-Existent Law

Confusing Order Raises Suspicions

Lack of Explanations Aggravates Situation

Debate About AI in the Judiciary Gains Momentum

Seven world powers including the US, China, and Russia are spending €22 billion on a reactor in the south of France that aims to confine plasma at 150 million degrees Celsius, ten times the temperature of the Sun’s core, using a magnetic field capable of lifting an entire aircraft carrier.

Elon Musk’s internet comes to mobile: Starlink technology connects smartphones without an antenna via satellite, works even without carrier signal, already costs just US$10 extra in the US, and could arrive in Brazil as an included benefit.

While Brazil has been discussing bullet trains for 16 years, China delivers 5 new high-speed lines in 2026, surpasses 50,000 km of HSR, and moves 1 billion passengers in a single year.

With a wingspan of 152 meters, 76 tires, and a capacity to carry 1,270 tons, the Boeing Pelican was the giant “flying ship” that promised to cross oceans close to the water on an invisible air cushion beneath its wings.

A Chinese factory in Guangdong is assembling a humanoid robot every 30 minutes while Tesla, Figure, and Boston Dynamics still struggle to deliver 10 thousand per year.

While countries spend billions to draw water from the sea, a Nobel-winning scientist creates a container-sized machine that extracts up to 1,000 liters per day from dry air and uses ultrasound to release water in minutes, even in the middle of the desert.

Belgium will sink 23 giant concrete caissons, each weighing 22,000 tons, in the North Sea to build the world’s first artificial energy island 45 km off the coast, forming offshore electrical walls.

Few know, but India has a 36 km wall that surrounds a fort in the mountains and is considered the second largest in the world, behind the Great Wall of China.

Hyundai Creta 2029 appears in new spy shots with a completely revamped design, a more modern digital interior, a larger multimedia center, a more comfortable passenger seat, and electrification finally on the radar.

Former CIA analyst warns that China has already surpassed the US in missiles, electronic warfare, cyber, and military production, transforming the Pacific into a zone without safe spaces while Washington clings to its submarine advantage.

Home-built airplane by a Minas Gerais engineer uses car parts, such as a power window motor for the flaps and a tachometer on the dashboard. The project took six years, and the aircraft has autonomy to fly up to seven hours non-stop.

Judge Used AI to Issue Ruling Based on Non-Existent Law

Confusing Order Raises Suspicions

Lack of Explanations Aggravates Situation

Debate About AI in the Judiciary Gains Momentum

Seven world powers including the US, China, and Russia are spending €22 billion on a reactor in the south of France that aims to confine plasma at 150 million degrees Celsius, ten times the temperature of the Sun’s core, using a magnetic field capable of lifting an entire aircraft carrier.

Elon Musk’s internet comes to mobile: Starlink technology connects smartphones without an antenna via satellite, works even without carrier signal, already costs just US$10 extra in the US, and could arrive in Brazil as an included benefit.

While Brazil has been discussing bullet trains for 16 years, China delivers 5 new high-speed lines in 2026, surpasses 50,000 km of HSR, and moves 1 billion passengers in a single year.

With a wingspan of 152 meters, 76 tires, and a capacity to carry 1,270 tons, the Boeing Pelican was the giant “flying ship” that promised to cross oceans close to the water on an invisible air cushion beneath its wings.

A Chinese factory in Guangdong is assembling a humanoid robot every 30 minutes while Tesla, Figure, and Boston Dynamics still struggle to deliver 10 thousand per year.

While countries spend billions to draw water from the sea, a Nobel-winning scientist creates a container-sized machine that extracts up to 1,000 liters per day from dry air and uses ultrasound to release water in minutes, even in the middle of the desert.

Belgium will sink 23 giant concrete caissons, each weighing 22,000 tons, in the North Sea to build the world’s first artificial energy island 45 km off the coast, forming offshore electrical walls.

Few know, but India has a 36 km wall that surrounds a fort in the mountains and is considered the second largest in the world, behind the Great Wall of China.

Mayor creates a “prank” with fake speed cameras

Former Brazilian car washer who washed cars to help his family overcomes a daily commute of up to 8 buses and earns a PhD in Engineering in Australia.

Trump’s visit to China could reveal a future that scares workers: dark factories, robots working non-stop, and industrial jobs disappearing before the eyes of the United States.

Weak showers and low-pressure faucets may be caused by an invisible error in the plumbing system that plumbers resolve in a few minutes and completely changes the water pressure in the house.

Few know, but India has a 36 km wall that surrounds a fort in the mountains and is considered the second largest in the world, behind the Great Wall of China.

Hyundai Creta 2029 appears in new spy shots with a completely revamped design, a more modern digital interior, a larger multimedia center, a more comfortable passenger seat, and electrification finally on the radar.

Former CIA analyst warns that China has already surpassed the US in missiles, electronic warfare, cyber, and military production, transforming the Pacific into a zone without safe spaces while Washington clings to its submarine advantage.

Home-built airplane by a Minas Gerais engineer uses car parts, such as a power window motor for the flaps and a tachometer on the dashboard. The project took six years, and the aircraft has autonomy to fly up to seven hours non-stop.