Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
4 min of reading 
0 comments 
New Law Could Cost Billions to the Northeast and Compromise the Future of Renewable Energy in Brazil. With Job and Revenue Losses, Ceará and Maranhão Face a Blow to the Energy Transition.
An unexpected turnaround threatens to shake the foundations of the energy sector in Brazil, especially in the Northeast, a region that stands out as one of the biggest protagonists in the energy transition in the country.
With the recent approval of a controversial bill, the sustainability and economic future of states like Ceará and Maranhão are at risk.
In addition to jeopardizing job creation and revenue, the measure raises serious questions about governmental priorities for the energy sector and regional inequalities.
-
SpaceX sets share price at $135 and targets a historic $75 billion IPO to debut on Nasdaq with a trillion-dollar market value
-
While the world rushes to mine lithium from Congo and Chile, Brazil sits on one of the largest reserves and has barely begun to explore.
-
Heir worked at thirteen in an ice cream factory without revealing he was the owner’s son; today, at twenty-five, he leads the best-selling ice cream brand for home consumption in the Northeast, grosses almost R$ 300 million, has 145 stores, and competes with multinationals with regional flavors.
-
Lock manufacturer from Rio Grande do Sul invests R$ 150 million to surpass R$ 1 billion in revenue, create 200 jobs, and double storage capacity, while choosing Santa Catarina to set up a new logistics center and speed up deliveries in Southern Brazil.
How Does the Law Impact the Northeast?
The Bill 576/21, known as the legal framework for offshore wind power, contains a provision that exclusively favors coal-fired thermal plants, concentrated mainly in the South of the country.
While the original text set 2027 as the final deadline for the operation of these plants, the new measure extends this deadline only for those using domestic coal.
According to the newspaper O Povo, Carlos Baldi, president of Energia Pecém, states that this decision creates a disastrous scenario for the Northeast.
In Ceará, the Pecém 1 plant, which operates on imported coal, does not qualify for the benefits outlined by the bill.
This directly threatens 1,800 jobs and could result in an annual revenue loss of R$ 200 million.
In Maranhão, where Energia Pecém also controls the Itaqui thermal plant, the estimated losses total R$ 160 million annually and the elimination of more than 650 job positions.
“This provision clearly and unfairly discriminates against the Northeast,” Baldi said, emphasizing the need for equality among the projects from different regions of the country.
Billion-Dollar Economic Losses at Stake
The exclusion of northeastern states from the benefits brought by the law threatens not only jobs and immediate revenue but also the future of sustainable energy in the region.
According to calculations from Energia Pecém, in 15 years, the negative impact on public coffers could exceed R$ 3 billion just in Ceará.
These figures include the loss of taxes that would no longer be collected by the federal government, states, and municipalities, as well as a significant reduction in income generation for thousands of families.
“Without changes to the text, the impact on revenue will exceed R$ 5 billion, harming the economic and social development of the Northeast,” Baldi reinforced.
Challenges in the Energy Transition
Despite the challenges posed by the new bill, Pecém 1 is already working on decarbonizing its operations.
Having operated on coal since its inception, the thermal plant recently signed a contract with the Ceará Gas Company to convert coal into natural gas, a less polluting alternative.
Additionally, the plant hosted Brazil’s first green hydrogen pilot project, inaugurated in early 2023.
According to experts, these advancements place Ceará at the forefront of the energy transition in the country, but the approval of the provision could slow down these strategic initiatives.
The exclusion of the Northeast from tax exemptions, in turn, limits the modernization plans for the plant and compromises its competitiveness in the national energy market.
Why is Domestic Coal a Problem?
The coal used in the South of Brazil is of inferior quality compared to imported coal, according to sector analyses.
According to Baldi, the imported coal used by Pecém 1 offers greater calorific value and lower environmental impact, in addition to being more economical.
Therefore, the decision to import the fuel was a strategic choice to reduce operational costs and increase energy efficiency.
However, with the tax benefit restricted to domestic coal, northeastern plants become less competitive and may lose ground in the market.
Worrisome Scenario for Green Hydrogen
The measure may also jeopardize the development of the green hydrogen hub in the Pecém Industrial and Port Complex, which has already attracted billions in investments and positions Ceará as a reference in this strategic sector.
The project, which began implementation in 2023, represents an opportunity to establish Brazil as a leader in sustainable technologies.
However, the lack of adequate incentives threatens to delay the growth of this initiative and, with it, the chance of generating thousands of jobs in the region.
Uncertain Future and Regional Inequality
The approval of Bill 576/21 in its current terms not only exacerbates regional inequalities but also calls into question Brazil’s commitment to the energy transition.
While the South benefits from exclusive advantages, the Northeast, already facing historical development challenges, is penalized by a measure that does not take its specificities and technological advancements into account.
Is Brazil willing to sacrifice sustainability and the future of the Northeast in favor of localized interests?
Be the first to react!