Companies dismissed employees for just cause without evidence and are now paying compensation of up to R$ 100,000: TST establishes a thesis that presumes automatic moral damage when accusations of dishonesty are not confirmed.

Written by Douglas Avila

Published on 13/04/2026 at 19:02

Seja o primeiro a reagir!

TST Theme 62 establishes binding thesis: when a company dismisses for misconduct without proof, moral damages are automatically presumed and compensation can reach R$ 100,000

Accusing an employee of dishonesty without proof has always been risky. Now, it has become even more costly. The Superior Labor Court (TST) established a binding thesis — Theme 62 — that presumes automatic moral damage when a dismissal for just cause based on an accusation of misconduct is overturned by the courts due to lack of evidence. In practice, the company not only has to pay severance pay: it must also compensate the worker for damage to their honor, with amounts that have already reached R$ 100,000.

As published by the Reis Advocacia office, “being accused of dishonesty, even internally, deeply undermines self-esteem and professional reputation. An unjust cause is not merely an administrative error; it is a violation of honor.” The worker has up to two years after the end of the contract to file a lawsuit.

The cases of 2026 that show how the Justice system is punishing unjust dismissals

Recent decisions illustrate the direct application of Theme 62:

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW

See also

Banker from Banco do Brasil — accused of embezzlement without proof, reinstated with compensation of R$ 100,000 by the SDI-2 of the TST
Ramp assistant from Swissport (Brasília airport) — dismissed for a migraine crisis, just cause overturned, compensation of R$ 15,000
Worker at TRT-15 (Campinas) — accused of fraud in a medical certificate (CID Z02.7), just cause overturned with compensation of R$ 5,837.64 (three salaries)
Case from Espírito Santo — TST confirms binding thesis in March 2026, with compensation of R$ 15,000

In all cases, the company failed to prove the accusation — and paid for it. In addition to moral compensations, companies bore the costs of prior notice, proportional 13th salary, 40% fine on FGTS, withdrawal from FGTS, and unemployment insurance.

Another recent case that drew attention involved a worker dismissed for missing work to care for a sick child, who overturned the just cause in court with a decision that surprised companies.

Why moral damage is now automatic — and what this changes for companies

Judge Marina de Siqueira Ferreira Zerbinatti, rapporteur of one of the cases at TRT-15, explained the logic: the company “imputed to the author a fact capable of tarnishing their honor, for reasons that were not subsequently proven.” Thus, the mere act of accusing without proof already constitutes damage — it is not necessary for the worker to demonstrate specific suffering.

This automatic presumption (in re ipsa) completely changes the risk calculation for HR departments. Previously, the company could dismiss for just cause and, in the worst-case scenario, only pay severance if it lost in court. Now, moral compensation comes along — and is proportional to the company’s economic capacity.

As highlighted by Santos Faria Advocacia, the TST thesis is also educational: it seeks to deter dismissals for just cause used as tools of intimidation or retaliation.

Facade of the Superior Labor Court in Brasília

When just cause is upheld — and what the worker should know

Automatic moral damage does not apply to all cases of reversal. If the company has proof of the serious misconduct — even if insufficient for just cause — the court may overturn the dismissal without granting moral compensation. The presumption exists only when the accusation of misconduct (dishonesty) is shown to be completely unfounded.

Additionally, proportionality and immediacy remain essential criteria. The Seventh Panel of the TST annulled a just cause from J.B.S. because the company took four months to apply the punishment — even with a history of infractions by the employee. As published by Migalhas, another decision overturned the just cause of an employee who used stock medication for the first time — the maximum punishment for a first infraction was deemed disproportionate.

The worker has two years after termination to file a lawsuit. Experts recommend keeping all documentation: internal communications, emails, testimonies from colleagues, and any record of the accusation made by the company.

0 Comentários

Mais recente

Mais antigos Mais votado

Feedbacks

Visualizar todos comentários

Companies dismissed employees for just cause without evidence and are now paying compensation of up to R$ 100,000: TST establishes a thesis that presumes automatic moral damage when accusations of dishonesty are not confirmed.

TST Theme 62 establishes binding thesis: when a company dismisses for misconduct without proof, moral damages are automatically presumed and compensation can reach R$ 100,000

The cases of 2026 that show how the Justice system is punishing unjust dismissals

Why moral damage is now automatic — and what this changes for companies

When just cause is upheld — and what the worker should know

Scientists enter a narrow, flooded cave 500 meters deep and find giant dinosaur footprints on the ceiling measuring up to 1.25 meters, preserved in such a rare way that a new type of trace had to be created.

A giant half-ton ring fell in Kenya from space, and more than a year later, scientists still do not know where it came from.

In Botswana, a salt flat of up to 16,000 km² that was once an African megalake spends months as an absolute white desert, but during the rainy season it transforms into a shallow sea that reappears from nowhere and can be seen from space in the middle of southern Africa.

After two years of internal discussions, Paraguay has finally regulated the law that opens the country to foreign technology and service companies with tax incentives that promise to create thousands of jobs and change the economy.

Map reveals how the Earth may look in 250 million years: continents will reunite in the Last Pangaea, 92% of the planet could become uninhabitable for mammals, and Spain appears among the rare possible exceptions.

About 6,000 residents live concentrated along a single street nearly 9 km long in the interior of Poland, with houses forming a continuous row and narrow agricultural strips emerging behind them, creating one of the most unusual rural patterns in Europe.

With 1,000 buses sent abroad, the Brazilian manufacturer consolidates the strength of national technology and takes on a leading role in public transportation across all of Latin America.

The Federal Revenue Service is cross-referencing data from Pix, cryptocurrencies, and cashback from 46 million Brazilians for the 2026 income tax, and those who do not declare by May 29 may face a fine of up to 20% of the tax owed.

New law sanctioned by Lula prioritizes cancer vaccines in the SUS and ensures free access to personalized treatments that could revolutionize the way Brazil fights the disease.

A new cold front is scheduled to arrive and will change the weather in three regions of Brazil with heavy rain, storms, and a sharp drop in temperature that could bring thermometers close to 8 degrees.

Children who care for elderly parents can now receive more than 800 reais per month in Paraná with the Bolsa Cuidador program, which is already operating in 20 cities and may expand to more municipalities.

Humanity has returned to orbit the Moon after 50 years, but two more risky missions are still needed before an astronaut finally sets foot on the lunar surface again in 2028.

Companies dismissed employees for just cause without evidence and are now paying compensation of up to R$ 100,000: TST establishes a thesis that presumes automatic moral damage when accusations of dishonesty are not confirmed.

TST Theme 62 establishes binding thesis: when a company dismisses for misconduct without proof, moral damages are automatically presumed and compensation can reach R$ 100,000

The cases of 2026 that show how the Justice system is punishing unjust dismissals

Why moral damage is now automatic — and what this changes for companies

When just cause is upheld — and what the worker should know

Scientists enter a narrow, flooded cave 500 meters deep and find giant dinosaur footprints on the ceiling measuring up to 1.25 meters, preserved in such a rare way that a new type of trace had to be created.

A giant half-ton ring fell in Kenya from space, and more than a year later, scientists still do not know where it came from.

In Botswana, a salt flat of up to 16,000 km² that was once an African megalake spends months as an absolute white desert, but during the rainy season it transforms into a shallow sea that reappears from nowhere and can be seen from space in the middle of southern Africa.

After two years of internal discussions, Paraguay has finally regulated the law that opens the country to foreign technology and service companies with tax incentives that promise to create thousands of jobs and change the economy.

Map reveals how the Earth may look in 250 million years: continents will reunite in the Last Pangaea, 92% of the planet could become uninhabitable for mammals, and Spain appears among the rare possible exceptions.

About 6,000 residents live concentrated along a single street nearly 9 km long in the interior of Poland, with houses forming a continuous row and narrow agricultural strips emerging behind them, creating one of the most unusual rural patterns in Europe.

With 1,000 buses sent abroad, the Brazilian manufacturer consolidates the strength of national technology and takes on a leading role in public transportation across all of Latin America.

The Federal Revenue Service is cross-referencing data from Pix, cryptocurrencies, and cashback from 46 million Brazilians for the 2026 income tax, and those who do not declare by May 29 may face a fine of up to 20% of the tax owed.

A new cold front is scheduled to arrive and will change the weather in three regions of Brazil with heavy rain, storms, and a sharp drop in temperature that could bring thermometers close to 8 degrees.

Humanity has returned to orbit the Moon after 50 years, but two more risky missions are still needed before an astronaut finally sets foot on the lunar surface again in 2028.

Humanoid robotics has always been the domain of technology giants, but this cheap and accessible robot could change everything by opening doors for universities, startups, and independent inventors around the world.

Built in the 1980s to prevent exactly this scenario, Saudi Arabia’s main oil pipeline was hit by a drone hours after a ceasefire, cutting 700,000 barrels per day and causing oil prices to rise back to $100.

The Federal Revenue Service is cross-referencing data from Pix, cryptocurrencies, and cashback from 46 million Brazilians for the 2026 income tax, and those who do not declare by May 29 may face a fine of up to 20% of the tax owed.

New law sanctioned by Lula prioritizes cancer vaccines in the SUS and ensures free access to personalized treatments that could revolutionize the way Brazil fights the disease.

A new cold front is scheduled to arrive and will change the weather in three regions of Brazil with heavy rain, storms, and a sharp drop in temperature that could bring thermometers close to 8 degrees.

Children who care for elderly parents can now receive more than 800 reais per month in Paraná with the Bolsa Cuidador program, which is already operating in 20 cities and may expand to more municipalities.

Humanity has returned to orbit the Moon after 50 years, but two more risky missions are still needed before an astronaut finally sets foot on the lunar surface again in 2028.