Scholar Required to Return R$ 245,000 to Capes After Maintaining Employment During Postdoctoral Fellowship

Written by Andriely Medeiros de Araújo

Published on 23/10/2025 at 20:26

No âmbito de um contrato de bolsa de pós-doutorado, pesquisadora da Ufes descumpriu regras como dedicação exclusiva e conclusão do curso, e foi determinada a devolver R$ 245 mil aos cofres públicos.

5 people reacted to this.

In The Scope Of A Postdoctoral Fellowship Contract, Ufes Researcher Violated Rules Such As Exclusive Dedication And Program Completion, And Was Ordered To Return R$ 245 Thousand To The Public Treasury.

A researcher linked to the Federal University of Espírito Santo (Ufes) is required to return R$ 245,140.82 to the public coffers due to a breach of the postdoctoral contract from the Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel (Capes). The decision was made by the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) in a session held on October 21, 2025, after identifying irregularities in complying with the conditions of the fellowship.

The postdoctoral program was supposed to be completed with exclusive dedication, but the researcher maintained an employment relationship and did not finish the program.

The case takes place in the state of Espírito Santo, within the Ufes framework, and highlights failures in the oversight of postdoctoral fellowships in federal institutions.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW

Postdoctoral Contract And Obligations

The TCU found that the beneficiary of the fellowship signed a grant agreement that required exclusive dedication to research during the postdoctoral period.

Despite this, she maintained an employment relationship concurrently with the program from July 2015 to January 2018.

Furthermore, she did not complete the postdoctoral program for which she was awarded.

Capes originally allocated an amount of R$ 147,600, through 36 installments of R$ 4,100, during the indicated period.

With monetary correction, the amount to be returned reaches R$ 245,140.82.

Decision, Deadlines And Consequences

In the session on 10/21/2025, the TCU deemed the accounts presented by the researcher to be irregular and ordered the return of the amount to the public treasury.

The Court stipulated that the first payment should be made within 15 days; if there is no voluntary payment, judicial collection measures may be adopted.

The agency will also notify Capes to take appropriate administrative action.

Researcher’s Defense

The researcher presented a defense claiming that she did not act in bad faith and that, according to her, other funding agencies allow employment relationships in postdoctoral fellowships.

She also argued that the requirement for full dedication would be illegal, since the employment relationship would not occur at the granting institution, but rather in providing services.

Despite these claims, the TCU did not accept the arguments. The understanding was that each notice has the force of a contract and those who accept the fellowship must comply with the clauses they sign.

Impacts On Postdoctoral Fellowships And Institutions

This case sheds light on one of the critical vectors of postdoctoral fellowships in Brazil: the requirement to comply with contractual conditions, such as exclusive dedication, program completion, and accountability.

When these steps are not observed, the result can be the return of public funds and the liability of the fellow.

For Ufes, even without directly granting the fellowship or having a formal relationship with the researcher (since she was not a civil servant or permanent professor), the situation raises questions about the monitoring of postdoctoral compliance.

In broader terms, the outcome reinforces the need for educational and research institutions to establish more rigorous monitoring mechanisms for postdoctoral fellowships, ensuring that the benefiting researchers meet deadlines, deliver results, and dedicate themselves as per the contract.

What Is Postdoctoral Study And Why This Case Matters

The postdoctoral fellowship modality refers to a research stage conducted by those who already hold a doctorate, aiming to deepen or expand their academic investigations, typically at a national or international institution.

When a fellow does not fulfill their obligations — as in the case of the Ufes researcher —, there is an impact not only financially but also reputationally for the institution and the research funding system.

Moreover, the use of public resources requires transparency and responsibility: each fellowship awarded for postdoctoral research represents an investment in knowledge, innovation, and training researchers who can contribute to society.

When the conditions are not met, this cycle is interrupted, which undermines science & technology policies.

Paths To Avoid New Cases And Recommendations

To strengthen the credibility of the postdoctoral system, it is recommended that:

Educational and research institutions establish continuous monitoring of postdoctoral fellowships, checking deadlines, dedication, and employment relationships of fellows;
Fellows receiving postdoctoral fellowships assume clear responsibility and fully understand the contractual clauses they sign, including the requirements for exclusive dedication or professional ties;
Funding agencies reinforce compliance processes (such as checking dedication, ties, and research completion) so that isolated cases do not weaken the system as a whole.

This episode highlights how fulfilling obligations in postdoctoral contracts is vital for maintaining a quality and trustworthy university environment.

The proper return of public resources ultimately represents more than a simple financial restitution: it symbolizes a commitment to serious research, transparency, and the responsible use of the postdoctoral fellowship.

With information from Folha Vitória.

0 Comments

most recent

older Most voted

Scholar Required to Return R$ 245,000 to Capes After Maintaining Employment During Postdoctoral Fellowship

In The Scope Of A Postdoctoral Fellowship Contract, Ufes Researcher Violated Rules Such As Exclusive Dedication And Program Completion, And Was Ordered To Return R$ 245 Thousand To The Public Treasury.

Postdoctoral Contract And Obligations

Decision, Deadlines And Consequences

Researcher’s Defense

Impacts On Postdoctoral Fellowships And Institutions

What Is Postdoctoral Study And Why This Case Matters

Paths To Avoid New Cases And Recommendations

Libya built over 4,000 kilometers of underground pipelines to bring water from the Sahara to coastal cities in a project that the government itself called the Eighth Wonder of the World.

Desert sand, previously discarded for being too smooth for concrete, becomes an ecological brick in the United Arab Emirates, dispensing with Portland cement, curing at room temperature, and attempting to transform dunes useless for construction into raw material for a new arid engineering.

He transformed an abandoned plastic water tank into an underground house in the “hobbit hole” style, using only repurposed pallet wood, without heavy machinery or expensive labor.

China transforms desert-devastated area into the world’s largest artificial forest, planting trees for 60 years, blocking sand that reached Beijing, and creating a “green lung” of 92,000 hectares in a region once considered lost.

Toyota launches “family hybrid van” with 7 or 8 seats, 1.8 hybrid engine, fuel consumption of up to 23.8 km/l, and a price equivalent to about R$ 104,000 without taxes, below the Tiggo 8 Pro Plug-in Hybrid sold in Brazil: meet the Noah Hybrid 2026 in Japan.

With 70 tons of rock removed by hand and an 800-year-old abandoned cave, a former businessman transforms a dark shelter into a modern home carved in the heart of the forest.

Engine without traditional cylinder head could change the future of hybrids: Aramco creates DHE technology that simplifies mechanics, promises to reduce consumption by up to 25%, and challenges decades of evolution in combustion engines.

At 75 years old, Mr. Izidro planted 400,000 trees over decades in Paraná, transformed a 2.42 million m² property into a green refuge in the Guartelá Canyon, and leaves a legacy with over 100,000 endangered araucarias.

Bacteria hidden in the freezing waters of Antarctica intrigues scientists by producing a rare compound that targets melanoma cells without affecting healthy tissues.

11-year-old girl sees that the family didn’t have money for her father’s headstone, sets up a lemonade stand and raises almost $3,000 with the help of the community.

Archaeologists excavating a train project in France have found, under meters of mud from the Seine River, a Mesolithic camp from 10,000 years ago that seemed to have disappeared from human history.

Son finds father’s forgotten notebooks and helps scientists solve the mystery of a 55-million-year-old marine fossil that remained unanswered for almost three decades.

Scholar Required to Return R$ 245,000 to Capes After Maintaining Employment During Postdoctoral Fellowship

In The Scope Of A Postdoctoral Fellowship Contract, Ufes Researcher Violated Rules Such As Exclusive Dedication And Program Completion, And Was Ordered To Return R$ 245 Thousand To The Public Treasury.

Postdoctoral Contract And Obligations

Decision, Deadlines And Consequences

Researcher’s Defense

Impacts On Postdoctoral Fellowships And Institutions

What Is Postdoctoral Study And Why This Case Matters

Paths To Avoid New Cases And Recommendations

Libya built over 4,000 kilometers of underground pipelines to bring water from the Sahara to coastal cities in a project that the government itself called the Eighth Wonder of the World.

Desert sand, previously discarded for being too smooth for concrete, becomes an ecological brick in the United Arab Emirates, dispensing with Portland cement, curing at room temperature, and attempting to transform dunes useless for construction into raw material for a new arid engineering.

He transformed an abandoned plastic water tank into an underground house in the “hobbit hole” style, using only repurposed pallet wood, without heavy machinery or expensive labor.

China transforms desert-devastated area into the world’s largest artificial forest, planting trees for 60 years, blocking sand that reached Beijing, and creating a “green lung” of 92,000 hectares in a region once considered lost.

Toyota launches “family hybrid van” with 7 or 8 seats, 1.8 hybrid engine, fuel consumption of up to 23.8 km/l, and a price equivalent to about R$ 104,000 without taxes, below the Tiggo 8 Pro Plug-in Hybrid sold in Brazil: meet the Noah Hybrid 2026 in Japan.

With 70 tons of rock removed by hand and an 800-year-old abandoned cave, a former businessman transforms a dark shelter into a modern home carved in the heart of the forest.

Engine without traditional cylinder head could change the future of hybrids: Aramco creates DHE technology that simplifies mechanics, promises to reduce consumption by up to 25%, and challenges decades of evolution in combustion engines.

Central Bank changes rule that lasted decades and allows dollar and euro accounts in Brazil for exporters and companies with foreign capital, eliminating the need for currency exchange in some transfers starting in October 2026.

The Central Bank ends the R$ 500 limit on Pix by approximation, and account holders will be able to use the general Pix limit to pay any amount by tapping their phone on the terminal starting in October 2026.

PIX from BRICS becomes reality: BRICS Pay advances to enable international payments without the dollar; system inspired by Pix and based on blockchain could move up to 20% of global trade by 2030, while bloc countries already account for 40% of the world economy.

After a motorcycle accident at 17, a Bahian agronomist borrowed R$ 40 from his mother, transformed a homemade granola recipe into Tia Sônia, and reached R$ 120 million, targeting São Paulo with 300 tons monthly and 80 products.

At 75 years old, Mr. Izidro planted 400,000 trees over decades in Paraná, transformed a 2.42 million m² property into a green refuge in the Guartelá Canyon, and leaves a legacy with over 100,000 endangered araucarias.

Bacteria hidden in the freezing waters of Antarctica intrigues scientists by producing a rare compound that targets melanoma cells without affecting healthy tissues.

11-year-old girl sees that the family didn’t have money for her father’s headstone, sets up a lemonade stand and raises almost $3,000 with the help of the community.

Archaeologists excavating a train project in France have found, under meters of mud from the Seine River, a Mesolithic camp from 10,000 years ago that seemed to have disappeared from human history.

Son finds father’s forgotten notebooks and helps scientists solve the mystery of a 55-million-year-old marine fossil that remained unanswered for almost three decades.