Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
4 min of reading 
0 comments 
Court Allows Company to Require Employees to Log Bathroom Visits, Sparking Debate Over Labor Rights and Potential Health Impacts.
In a world where discussions about reducing working hours and improving labor conditions are prevalent, a Swiss court made a surprising decision that is causing international stir.
The controversy involves requiring employees to log the time spent on bathroom visits. That’s right!
The decision raises delicate questions about labor rights and what can truly be considered part of the workday.
-
Without radar, without fines, and without physical barriers: a red road in India uses smart asphalt with different colors and textures to reduce vehicle speed and protect wildlife in a natural and efficient way.
-
Thousands of small fish were caught climbing a 15-meter vertical waterfall in the Congo using microscopic hooks on their fins in a nearly 10-hour journey that defies gravity.
-
Archaeologists found in the Tyrrhenian Sea, a few kilometers from Rome, a submerged Roman structure about 50 meters long, with concentric walls, noble floors, and signs of an elite villa preserved under the waters.
-
BBC announces largest staff cut in 15 years with 2,000 layoffs to save 3.2 billion reais while facing a 10 billion dollar lawsuit filed by Donald Trump in the United States.
Court Rules on Bathroom Breaks
In a trial that is already being viewed as potentially dangerous for the working class, the Swiss Public Law Court issued a verdict allowing the company Jean Singer et Cie, specialized in watch displays, to require its employees to clock out when leaving for physiological needs.
According to the ruling, released in September 2024, Swiss labor law does not expressly prohibit the logging of such breaks, creating a loophole that can be exploited by other companies.
How Did the Controversy Begin?
According to the Swiss channel RTS, the litigation began in 2021 when inspectors from the Office of Labor Relations and Conditions (ORCT) in Neuchâtel checked whether Covid-19 protection guidelines were being followed at Jean Singer.
During the inspection, it was discovered that the company was monitoring its employees’ bathroom visits, counting that time as “non-worked” and therefore unpaid.
This immediately raised concerns at the ORCT, which argued that such a practice could encourage employees to become dehydrated or hold back, potentially leading to serious health issues, such as kidney problems.
As a result, in February 2022, the agency prohibited Jean Singer from continuing this practice, stating that the time necessary for physiological needs should not be treated as a conventional break.
The Court Decision and the Gender Controversy
The company, however, appealed the decision. To the surprise of many, including labor experts, the Court ruled in favor of Jean Singer.
The rationale was that Swiss labor legislation does not specify that going to the bathroom is a paid labor right, except when it occurs during a formal break provided by law.
This decision, however, brought to light an even more controversial point: gender discrimination.
The court acknowledged that women may be adversely affected by the requirement to log bathroom visits, particularly due to physiological issues like the menstrual cycle, which necessitates more frequent and longer trips to the restroom.
The court urged the company to review its practices and seek solutions to reduce this inequality.
What Does Swiss Legislation Say About Breaks?
The Swiss Labor Law requires companies to ensure breaks during the workday. According to Article 15, the rest time varies based on the length of the work shift:
- 15 minutes for a day longer than 5 and a half hours,
- 30 minutes for a day longer than 7 hours,
- 1 hour for a day longer than 9 hours.
These breaks must be paid, as long as the employee remains on the workplace premises.
However, there is no direct mention of physiological needs, which left room for Jean Singer to argue that bathroom usage should be counted as part of these breaks.
Company Justification
Pascal Moesch, legal representative of Jean Singer, publicly defended the company’s and the court’s decision, stating that, whether it’s a break for the bathroom, meals, or rest, all work interruptions must be logged and unpaid.
According to him, the company has a policy that employees should use regular breaks to go to the bathroom, suggesting that this time should be deducted from their working hours.
Repercussions in Switzerland
The decision caused a stir among labor organizations and unions in Switzerland. Florence Nater, the state counselor responsible for labor issues, expressed concern about the impact of this measure.
She fears that other companies may adopt similar practices, leading to an erosion of workers’ rights. “I hope this decision does not serve as a model for other companies,” Nater stated.
Despite the controversy, Swiss employers have been trying to minimize the impact of the decision.
Bárbara Zimmermann-Gerster, from the employers’ association, argued that this policy does not represent a standard for companies in Switzerland.
She emphasized that, amid a growing shortage of skilled labor, it is essential for companies to offer attractive working conditions to retain their employees.
Ethical Issues and Possible Developments
The decision raises important questions about the limits of corporate control over workers’ private lives.
The fact that a basic physiological need like going to the bathroom could be treated as unpaid time can affect the physical and mental health of workers and harm the relationship between employers and employees.
Additionally, the gender discrimination mentioned by the court highlights how seemingly neutral measures can disproportionately impact different groups.
What will happen as a result of this decision? Will companies around the world follow Jean Singer’s example, or will Swiss lawmakers seek to close this legal loophole?
Do you think this practice of logging bathroom time could spread to other companies? Would your company do something like this? Share your opinion in the comments!
Seja o primeiro a reagir!