Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
4 min of reading 
0 comments 
Lula Government Announced Tax Exemption on Essential Foods Like Coffee, Olive Oil, and Meat. However, the Measure Was Received with Skepticism. Economists Warn That, Despite Good Intentions, the Measure May Be Ineffective and Not Reduce Prices. Understand Why This Decision May Not Make a Difference in Brazilians’ Wallets!
In an attempt to alleviate costs for Brazilians, the government of Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva announced on Thursday, March 6, 2025, the exemption of taxes on the importation of nine essential foods.
Among the benefited items are coffee, olive oil, sugar, corn, sunflower oil, sardines, biscuits, pasta, and meats.
Although the measure has generated expectations of a possible drop in prices for these products, the reality may be very different from what many imagine.
-
China alone accounts for 70% of trade within the BRICS, while Brazil establishes itself as an essential supplier of food and minerals: understand how the group, which already represents nearly 40% of the world’s GDP, is changing the game.
-
Starting in May, those who do not have registered biometrics will not be able to apply for Bolsa Família, sickness benefits, or unemployment insurance: understand the new rule that changes access to benefits for millions of Brazilians.
-
A new law being voted on in Brazil proposes a minimum fare of R$ 10 per trip and R$ 2.50 per kilometer for Uber and 99 drivers, and promises to ensure they earn as well as taxi drivers did during the golden age of taxis in the country.
-
Bauer Group collapses after failed judicial recovery: 25 years, 800 vehicles, and a network of gas stations leave a debt of R$ 50 million and 100 layoffs, exposing costs, tight margins, and expensive credit in Brazil.
Experts Warn That the Measure May Have a Limited, If Any, Impact on Market Prices.
The federal government’s decision comes at a time of persistent inflation, especially in the food sector.
However, the promised financial relief for consumers may be insignificant.
The impact of the tax reduction, although symbolically important, is relatively small when analyzed from a numerical perspective.
The tax exemption Covers Only a Fraction of Brazilian Imports, Which May Result in a Minimal Effect on Final Prices.
Measure May Not Affect Prices
According to an analysis conducted by the Poder 360 portal, based on data provided by the Ministry of Development, Industry, Commerce, and Services, the products that had the tax rate eliminated represent an extremely small portion of total imports made by Brazil in 2024.
These foods account for only 1% of all that Brazil imported last year.
To gain a clearer idea of the impact, products like sugar, beef, and coffee have even lower representation: sugar accounts for only 0.04% of imports, beef 0.02%, and coffee, just 0.003%.
This statistic raises an important question: if Brazil is already one of the largest producers of many of these items, will the tax exemption have a real impact on domestic prices?
The answer from many experts is negative, since the measure does not directly affect domestic production.
Furthermore, in a scenario of increasing international demand, as seen with coffee and corn, the tax exemption may not be enough to contain price pressures.
Instead of a reduction, some warn of the risk of an increase in prices for these products, especially in the case of corn, which is sensitive to global dynamics.
The Impact on Productive Sectors
The reaction from producers and economists to the announcement was cautious.
For Paulo Bertolini, president of the Brazilian Association of Corn Producers (Abramilho), the government’s measure will be “ineffective”.
He argues that by announcing the tax exemption on food like corn, the government is only signaling an intervention in the market, without understanding the complexities of international prices.
Bertolini states that although Brazil is one of the world’s largest corn producers, the product is facing a surge in global prices, something that cannot be combated simply with a tax exemption.
Corn, which is the third largest agricultural product in Brazil in terms of production and the second largest in exports, is experiencing rising prices due to factors such as a temporary scarcity caused by the off-season.
This rise in prices in the global market directly affects the domestic market, making it challenging for the government’s fiscal policy to have a noticeable impact on reducing costs for consumers.
Coffee Prices and International Dynamics
The coffee scenario, which was also included in the list of products with tax exemption, follows the same line of reasoning.
According to experts, the issue of coffee prices is not a purely national problem, but rather a global one.
Brazil, despite being the world’s largest producer, faces rising coffee prices due to unfavorable climatic conditions in various parts of the world, as well as other factors affecting global production, such as the increasing demand for high-quality beans and currency volatility.
The solution to high coffee prices, therefore, does not depend on tax exemptions or import policies, but rather on a series of structural issues in the global agricultural sector.
The director of institutional relations of the Brazilian Association of Soluble Coffee Industry (Abics), Aguinaldo Lima, emphasized that the exemption measure is unlikely to generate price reductions since the problem is a global issue.
He further explained that despite large Brazilian production, the increase in prices in the domestic market is directly linked to the appreciation of the product in the international market, which makes the local effect practically irrelevant.
Measures That Could Be More Effective
Instead of a targeted tax exemption, some experts suggest that the government could adopt other more effective measures to control food inflation.
Among the suggestions are the adoption of policies to encourage domestic production in more affected areas, such as corn and coffee, and the creation of regulatory stocks to soften prices during periods of seasonal highs.
These strategies, along with stricter oversight on unjustified price increases, could bring real relief to consumers’ wallets.
Another important point raised by economists is that the tax exemption may have the opposite effect, with a potential increase in domestic prices due to speculative stockpiling.
This occurs because by reducing import costs, companies may seek to maximize their profits without passing the benefit on to the final consumer.
Therefore, the tax exemption measure may end up becoming just a political marketing ploy, failing to achieve the desired results.
Seja o primeiro a reagir!