Man Steals 1 Kg of Meat from Supermarket, Is Convicted and Is Acquitted by the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) Based on the Principle of Insignificance

Written by Felipe Alves da Silva

Published on 17/10/2025 at 21:07

STJ absolve homem que furtou carne congelada para alimentar filhos, aplicando o princípio da insignificância em decisão humanitária.

40 people reacted to this.

Superior Court of Justice Recognized That the Theft of Low-Value Food Recovered by the Establishment Does Not Cause Property Damage and Allows Acquittal Even in Cases of Recidivism

The Superior Court of Justice (STJ) decided to acquit a man sentenced to 1 year and 2 months in prison for stealing about 1.1 kg of meat from a supermarket. The decision, reported by Minister Marluce Caldas, recognized that, even in the presence of a criminal record, it is possible to apply the principle of insignificance when the stolen item is food, of low value, and recovered by the establishment.

The case reignited the debate about the limits of criminal punishment in situations involving basic needs and social vulnerability. The man claimed to have stolen the food to feed his four children, an argument that weighed in the court’s final understanding.

Even as a Recidivist, Defendant is Acquitted for Act Considered to Have No Penal Relevance

The man had initially been convicted by the São Paulo Court of Justice (TJ-SP), which upheld the sentence on the grounds that the defendant was a recidivist and, therefore, did not fall under the so-called theft out of hunger — that committed by someone acting in a state of hunger or extreme need.
The São Paulo court also argued that since the meat was frozen, it was not intended for immediate consumption, which would rule out the possibility of applying the principle of excludent of unlawfulness.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW

STJ Reinforces Trend of Recognizing Insignificance in Food Theft

According to information published by the Consultor Jurídico magazine, the decision follows a recent trend from the STJ to consider thefts of essential goods like food and personal hygiene items to be insignificant, provided they are of trivial value and do not harm the owner.
The minister pointed out that isolated recidivism is not enough to deny the application of the principle when the conduct shows minimal offensiveness, absence of social dangerousness, and low degree of reproach.

In her decision, Caldas was emphatic:

“The application of the principle of insignificance is admitted when the res furtivae refers to a low-value food or hygiene item, as in this case, simple theft of beef and pork, valued at less than 10% of the current minimum wage, where the conduct did not cause any property damage, since the goods were returned to the supermarket.”

The case adds to the list of decisions that recognize the right to acquittal in situations of social vulnerability, opening an important precedent for similar cases.

Decision May Influence Future Judgments and Reinforces Humanitarian Role of Justice

Although the topic still generates divergence in lower courts, the STJ’s decision reinforces a more humanized view of penal application. For experts, the understanding seeks to differentiate acts of real necessity from criminal practices motivated by property gain.

According to legal scholars consulted by ConJur, this type of decision does not encourage crime but reaffirms that Criminal Law should be the last resort, reserved for truly harmful conducts.
Thus, the court reaffirms the principle that Justice should act with proportionality and social sensitivity, especially in cases involving hunger and survival.

The information was disclosed by the electronic magazine Consultor Jurídico (ConJur), based on Habeas Corpus 1.011.477 judged by Minister Marluce Caldas, of the Superior Court of Justice (STJ).

Man Steals 1 Kg of Meat from Supermarket, Is Convicted and Is Acquitted by the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) Based on the Principle of Insignificance

Superior Court of Justice Recognized That the Theft of Low-Value Food Recovered by the Establishment Does Not Cause Property Damage and Allows Acquittal Even in Cases of Recidivism

Even as a Recidivist, Defendant is Acquitted for Act Considered to Have No Penal Relevance

STJ Reinforces Trend of Recognizing Insignificance in Food Theft

Decision May Influence Future Judgments and Reinforces Humanitarian Role of Justice

Forget petroleum-based asphalt: a Scottish company transforms 684,000 plastic bottles into one kilometer of road that is 60% more resistant and up to 10 times more durable, and the technology has already started replacing traditional asphalt in more than 30 countries.

With billions in loans, China is rebuilding Nigeria’s railway network from scratch, abandoning the British colonial tracks that have turned to scrap and creating a corridor of over 1,300 km to take the load off the roads of Africa’s largest economy.

Austrian engineers have developed an inflatable concrete technology that transforms flat slabs into domes using only air pressure, eliminating scaffolding and temporary forms, and potentially changing the way bridges, tunnels, and curved roofs are constructed worldwide.

Australia prepares to dredge 96.5 million m³ in Moreton Bay to deepen, widen, and realign channels of the Port of Brisbane, in a project of up to 25 years designed to accommodate larger ships and enhance maritime safety and regional port efficiency.

Study solves great ancient mystery: remains of Philip II, father of Alexander the Great, are identified in Vergina and resolves the enigma of the Macedonian royal tombs that had lasted half a century.

Larger than the Toyota Hilux and with a towing capacity of 3.5 tons, the new MG U9 2026 features a 2.5 turbodiesel engine, 520 Nm, 4×4 traction with three locks, and an almost full-size build.

For the first time in history, a submarine cable will descend to four thousand meters deep under the ice of the North Pole to ensure that the internet between Europe and Asia no longer depends on conflict zones in the Middle East.

While the world discusses geopolitics, China is quietly closing a deal with its Kazakh neighbor to secure grain supplies during any global food crisis, with more than 3,600 Kazakh companies already able to export directly to the Chinese market.

A British company has installed in the middle of the ocean the world’s first floating platform that generates electricity 24 hours a day from the temperature difference between the surface and the depths of the Atlantic, without relying on wind or sun.

Amid the United States’ economic blockade, China delivers 15,000 tons of rice to Cuba as part of a 60,000-ton donation personally approved by Xi Jinping. The package includes 80 million dollars and solar panels for hospitals.

The James Webb telescope spotted a planet 700 light-years from Earth with mornings full of sand clouds and nights with clear skies, the temperature difference between the two hemispheres reaches an impressive 170 degrees.

Man Steals 1 Kg of Meat from Supermarket, Is Convicted and Is Acquitted by the Superior Court of Justice (STJ) Based on the Principle of Insignificance

Superior Court of Justice Recognized That the Theft of Low-Value Food Recovered by the Establishment Does Not Cause Property Damage and Allows Acquittal Even in Cases of Recidivism

Even as a Recidivist, Defendant is Acquitted for Act Considered to Have No Penal Relevance

STJ Reinforces Trend of Recognizing Insignificance in Food Theft

Decision May Influence Future Judgments and Reinforces Humanitarian Role of Justice

Forget petroleum-based asphalt: a Scottish company transforms 684,000 plastic bottles into one kilometer of road that is 60% more resistant and up to 10 times more durable, and the technology has already started replacing traditional asphalt in more than 30 countries.

With billions in loans, China is rebuilding Nigeria’s railway network from scratch, abandoning the British colonial tracks that have turned to scrap and creating a corridor of over 1,300 km to take the load off the roads of Africa’s largest economy.

Austrian engineers have developed an inflatable concrete technology that transforms flat slabs into domes using only air pressure, eliminating scaffolding and temporary forms, and potentially changing the way bridges, tunnels, and curved roofs are constructed worldwide.

Australia prepares to dredge 96.5 million m³ in Moreton Bay to deepen, widen, and realign channels of the Port of Brisbane, in a project of up to 25 years designed to accommodate larger ships and enhance maritime safety and regional port efficiency.

Study solves great ancient mystery: remains of Philip II, father of Alexander the Great, are identified in Vergina and resolves the enigma of the Macedonian royal tombs that had lasted half a century.

Larger than the Toyota Hilux and with a towing capacity of 3.5 tons, the new MG U9 2026 features a 2.5 turbodiesel engine, 520 Nm, 4×4 traction with three locks, and an almost full-size build.

Amid the United States’ economic blockade, China delivers 15,000 tons of rice to Cuba as part of a 60,000-ton donation personally approved by Xi Jinping. The package includes 80 million dollars and solar panels for hospitals.

For around 200 reais, anyone can buy a kit and have a chip implanted between their fingers to replace cards, keys, badges, and even medical information in case of a hospital emergency.

A 600-meter hill in the interior of Santa Catarina hides a volcanic past of almost 600 million years. The Morro do Garrafão in Corupá may have been an ancient extinct volcano, and science now confirms what the residents have always suspected.

Family has lived for over 50 years without electricity and running water at home in the South of Minas, 10 minutes from the city, improvising light, bath, and water while facing a lack of basic resources and awaiting property regularization.

Children from the 1980s and 1990s who spent hours playing in the street until dark naturally developed spatial intelligence, which today has become the subject of expensive courses, cognitive training, and modern methods of child and adult learning.

For the first time in history, a submarine cable will descend to four thousand meters deep under the ice of the North Pole to ensure that the internet between Europe and Asia no longer depends on conflict zones in the Middle East.

While the world discusses geopolitics, China is quietly closing a deal with its Kazakh neighbor to secure grain supplies during any global food crisis, with more than 3,600 Kazakh companies already able to export directly to the Chinese market.

A British company has installed in the middle of the ocean the world’s first floating platform that generates electricity 24 hours a day from the temperature difference between the surface and the depths of the Atlantic, without relying on wind or sun.

Amid the United States’ economic blockade, China delivers 15,000 tons of rice to Cuba as part of a 60,000-ton donation personally approved by Xi Jinping. The package includes 80 million dollars and solar panels for hospitals.

The James Webb telescope spotted a planet 700 light-years from Earth with mornings full of sand clouds and nights with clear skies, the temperature difference between the two hemispheres reaches an impressive 170 degrees.