Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
3 min of reading 
0 comments 
Argentina Analyzes Proposals from France and Germany to Restore Its Submarine Fleet, but Lack of Transparency in Negotiations Creates Uncertainty about the Future of the Navy.
In search of restoring its strategic presence in the South Atlantic, Argentina is studying proposals to rebuild its submarine capability, which is currently considered practically nonexistent. The Argentine Navy awaits concrete definitions from the Ministry of Defense, which is analyzing two international offers to acquire modern attack submarines, but the process still lacks transparency and effective progress.
Argentine Navy Seeks to Rescue Its Subsurface Force
After years of stagnation and the loss of the submarine ARA San Juan in 2017, the Argentine Navy has prioritized the rebuilding of its submarine force.
However, the recent Management Report No. 142, released by the Chief of Cabinet of the Minister, provided little clarification on the real progress of the negotiations, leaving gaps that create uncertainty within and outside the military sector.
-
Europe is trying to create an ammonia-powered marine engine without auxiliary fuel, which could unlock the race for giant emission-free ships. The technology aims to eliminate one of the biggest obstacles to clean maritime propulsion.
-
A 4,500-ton frigate with just over 100 crew members, state-of-the-art radar, and cruise missiles is being touted as the new standard of naval warfare in the 21st century.
-
The first commercial hydrogen-powered ferry enters operation in the U.S., eliminates the use of diesel, uses fuel cells to generate clean energy on board, and transforms San Francisco Bay into a landmark of the new era of emission-free navigation.
-
With a length of 121 meters and four rigid sails of 36 meters that automatically rotate to capture the wind, Canopée is the world’s first hybrid industrial cargo ship powered by wind, used to transport rockets and reduce fuel consumption by up to 30% on transoceanic routes.
France and Germany Compete for Billion-Dollar Contract
Among the proposals under analysis, two stand out: that of the French group Naval Group, which offers Scorpène-class submarines, and that of the German company ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS), with the Type 209NG model.
Both offers include the possibility of local construction, which would add value to the Argentine shipbuilding industry and foster jobs.
The German proposal gained special attention after the international press reported that the German government would be willing to guarantee up to US$ 4.27 billion to finance the sale, with deliveries expected over the next decade, according to documents sent to the German Budget Committee.
Response from the Argentine Government Raises Doubts
Despite ongoing negotiations, the official report does not mention either of the proposals directly.
When questioned by deputies about the plan to incorporate a new submarine into the Argentine Navy, the government limited itself to saying that it is “evaluating” alternatives, considering “technical, operational, financial, and strategic aspects,” in addition to possibilities for “international cooperation.”
This vague response, without direct mention of negotiations with Naval Group or TKMS, raises doubts about the pace of the decision-making process and about the government’s real willingness to commit to a long-term renewal of the fleet.
Used Submarines Still Considered
The absence of detailed information in the report also reopens speculation about the possible purchase of used submarines, retired from operation by other navies.
This scenario, already contemplated in previous analyses, raises concerns regarding the real modernization of the Argentine naval force and the operational effectiveness of the models that could be incorporated.
The recovery of submarine capability is vital for Argentina’s maritime sovereignty.
Without submarines in operation since the loss of ARA San Juan, the South American country has limited naval monitoring and projection, especially in economically significant areas such as the continental shelf and natural resource exploration zones.
Seja o primeiro a reagir!