Former National Treasury Secretary Warns Brazil Wasted Chance to Adopt Tax Cashback for the Poor and Creates Rule That Benefits the Rich While Pressuring the General Rate

Written by Maria Heloisa Barbosa Borges

Published on 01/09/2025 at 19:32

Updated on 01/09/2025 at 20:15

Em vez de devolver tributos para famílias vulneráveis, como fazem países vizinhos, Congresso preferiu reduzir a alíquota geral e acabou pressionando o sistema tributário.

5 people reacted to this.

Brazil Gave Up on a Tax Cashback Mechanism for the Poorest, Already Tested in Uruguay and in States Like Rio Grande do Sul, and Preferred to Reduce the Rate for Everyone. In Practice, the Policy Ended Up Benefiting Those Who Did Not Need It and Forcing Tax Increases in Other Sectors.

The debate on fiscal justice in Brazil gained a critical point with the decision not to implement the tax cashback for the poor, a simple mechanism that has been functioning in Uruguay and states like Rio Grande do Sul. The proposal, which would return part of the taxes to low-income families, was replaced by a reduction in the rate of basic food items for everyone — equally benefiting both the rich and the poor.

According to experts like Aod Cunha (former Secretary of Finance of RS and advisor to companies like Gerdau and Vibra) and Jefferson Bittencourt (former Secretary of the National Treasury and current Head of Macroeconomics at ASA Investments), this choice distorted the logic of tax reform and increased pressure on other sectors of the economy.

How Tax Cashback Works

The tax cashback model is based on a simple principle: low-income individuals pay normally at the register, but the system automatically refunds the tax amount, usually through the bill of the card or the CPF linked to social programs.

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW

Why the Proposal Did Not Advance in Brasília

During the processing of the consumption reform, a national model was proposed that would link cashback to the Bolsa Família. Thus, beneficiaries would be able to use the program card and receive back the tax portion on essential products.

However, Congress rejected the proposal. A general reduction in the basic food items rate was chosen instead, which extended the benefit to higher-income families as well. In practice, those who did not need it started receiving the same discount, and the government was forced to raise the modal rate applied to other products to compensate for loss of revenue.

Social and Economic Impacts of the Decision

Experts claim that this choice reflects Brazil’s historical difficulty in targeting social policies. By expanding benefits to everyone, the country ends up wasting resources that could be applied to health, education, and security.

Aod Cunha emphasizes that the decision increases the regressivity of the system: “A historical injustice was not corrected, and a model that protects those who do not need it was maintained.” Bittencourt warns that the lack of targeting reduces public spending efficiency, creating distortions that compromise fiscal balance in the medium term.

A Cultural and Political Problem

The case of tax cashback for the poor reveals a larger problem: the difficulty in accepting that public policies should be targeted to those who truly need them. In programs like Farmácia Popular, for example, anyone with a medical prescription can get free medications, including high-income individuals. This lack of criteria generates waste and pressures the budget.

As long as the distributive logic does not change, Brazil will continue to create broad, expensive, and poorly targeted policies that disproportionately help the wealthier classes and leave the most vulnerable uncovered.

Do you think that tax cashback for the poor should have been approved? Would this model work in Brazil, or is the general rate reduction the right path? Leave your opinion in the comments — we want to hear from those who live this in practice.

2 Comments

most recent

older Most voted

Fabio

#165919

02/09/2025 07:26

Os governantes são bons em fazer doação com o chapéu alheio. O que precisa é focar na saída do BF. Cadastro de emprego pra quem entrou. Chamar o beneficiado. Avisando: “arrumamos entrevista em tal lugar”. Não foi, seu benefício é cortado. Simples assim.

Respond

Silvia Maria Bellato Nogueira

#165752

01/09/2025 20:37

ISSO porque somos ‘****’ imagina se fôssemos capitalistas.

Respond

Former National Treasury Secretary Warns Brazil Wasted Chance to Adopt Tax Cashback for the Poor and Creates Rule That Benefits the Rich While Pressuring the General Rate

Brazil Gave Up on a Tax Cashback Mechanism for the Poorest, Already Tested in Uruguay and in States Like Rio Grande do Sul, and Preferred to Reduce the Rate for Everyone. In Practice, the Policy Ended Up Benefiting Those Who Did Not Need It and Forcing Tax Increases in Other Sectors.

How Tax Cashback Works

Why the Proposal Did Not Advance in Brasília

Social and Economic Impacts of the Decision

A Cultural and Political Problem

Mother and daughter build a 70 m² house with more than 8,000 discarded glass bottles and impress with their creativity; known as the Casa de Sal, the property is located on Itamaracá Island, in Pernambuco.

Workers were opening a new road connection near the Marginal Tietê when they found, in the underground of the construction site, remnants of locomotives, wagons, and boilers from the 19th century linked to the forgotten history of Lapa.

Instead of burning or burying old tires, an American city is transforming about 2,000 of them into the street itself, paving its first sections with a quieter and more durable rubber asphalt.

China transforms desert-devastated area into the world’s largest artificial forest, planting trees for 60 years, blocking sand that reached Beijing, and creating a “green lung” of 92,000 hectares in a region once considered lost.

Greek island offers free housing for volunteers, but there’s a condition: you need to take care of rescued cats.

Engineers want to carve through Africa with a giant canal to bring water from the world’s second-largest river to a dying lake on the edge of the Sahara Desert that has already lost 90% of its water.

China has deployed snake-shaped robots to slide along power lines, where they have already inspected over 130 kilometers of cables using cameras and sensors to detect damaged wires, worn-out parts, and overheating.

Without mortar, without water, and without mess: young people create a dry flooring system that fits ceramic tiles like a puzzle, reduces construction time, and promises to revolutionize the way floors are installed in civil construction.

A rare gas cuts through the hot springs in Zambia and reveals a deep fault that may penetrate the crust down to the Earth’s mantle.

Paper money is disappearing from Brazilians’ pockets, with the issuance of new banknotes dropping by 31% from 2020 to 2025, amid the explosion of Pix, which became the most frequent payment method for 46% of the population, while cash plummeted from 42% to 22%.

Ports without drivers and cabins already move containers like automated factories: robotic cranes, autonomous electric vehicles, and software transform giant terminals into 24-hour logistics machines.

They built an entire village of houses with their own hands made of earth and old tires, in the ecovillage Aardehuis, in the Netherlands, where 44 residents live in Earthships that generate almost all the energy, heat with the sun, and treat sewage in their own garden.

Former National Treasury Secretary Warns Brazil Wasted Chance to Adopt Tax Cashback for the Poor and Creates Rule That Benefits the Rich While Pressuring the General Rate

Brazil Gave Up on a Tax Cashback Mechanism for the Poorest, Already Tested in Uruguay and in States Like Rio Grande do Sul, and Preferred to Reduce the Rate for Everyone. In Practice, the Policy Ended Up Benefiting Those Who Did Not Need It and Forcing Tax Increases in Other Sectors.

How Tax Cashback Works

Why the Proposal Did Not Advance in Brasília

Social and Economic Impacts of the Decision

A Cultural and Political Problem

Mother and daughter build a 70 m² house with more than 8,000 discarded glass bottles and impress with their creativity; known as the Casa de Sal, the property is located on Itamaracá Island, in Pernambuco.

Workers were opening a new road connection near the Marginal Tietê when they found, in the underground of the construction site, remnants of locomotives, wagons, and boilers from the 19th century linked to the forgotten history of Lapa.

Instead of burning or burying old tires, an American city is transforming about 2,000 of them into the street itself, paving its first sections with a quieter and more durable rubber asphalt.

China transforms desert-devastated area into the world’s largest artificial forest, planting trees for 60 years, blocking sand that reached Beijing, and creating a “green lung” of 92,000 hectares in a region once considered lost.

Greek island offers free housing for volunteers, but there’s a condition: you need to take care of rescued cats.

Engineers want to carve through Africa with a giant canal to bring water from the world’s second-largest river to a dying lake on the edge of the Sahara Desert that has already lost 90% of its water.

China has deployed snake-shaped robots to slide along power lines, where they have already inspected over 130 kilometers of cables using cameras and sensors to detect damaged wires, worn-out parts, and overheating.

Paper money is disappearing from Brazilians’ pockets, with the issuance of new banknotes dropping by 31% from 2020 to 2025, amid the explosion of Pix, which became the most frequent payment method for 46% of the population, while cash plummeted from 42% to 22%.

Owner of Tok&Stok and Mobly raises alert in retail, sees debt exceed R$ 1 billion and rushes to court to try to save stores, jobs, and essential operations

China connects to the power grid the largest ultra-large battery storage station ever built in the world and signs a billion-dollar contract that consolidates a technology capable of sustaining entire cities with clean energy.

Casa CazéTV transforms internet chat into a live event during the World Cup, targeting over 100,000 fans in São Paulo and Rio, and boosts a Brazilian experience company that expects to grow up to 60% with shows, big screens, activations, and Brazil’s games.

Without mortar, without water, and without mess: young people create a dry flooring system that fits ceramic tiles like a puzzle, reduces construction time, and promises to revolutionize the way floors are installed in civil construction.

A rare gas cuts through the hot springs in Zambia and reveals a deep fault that may penetrate the crust down to the Earth’s mantle.

Paper money is disappearing from Brazilians’ pockets, with the issuance of new banknotes dropping by 31% from 2020 to 2025, amid the explosion of Pix, which became the most frequent payment method for 46% of the population, while cash plummeted from 42% to 22%.

Ports without drivers and cabins already move containers like automated factories: robotic cranes, autonomous electric vehicles, and software transform giant terminals into 24-hour logistics machines.

They built an entire village of houses with their own hands made of earth and old tires, in the ecovillage Aardehuis, in the Netherlands, where 44 residents live in Earthships that generate almost all the energy, heat with the sun, and treat sewage in their own garden.