1. Home
  2. / Interesting facts
  3. / UN Issues Urgent Warning: New Brazilian Law Could Accelerate Amazon Devastation and Ignore Rights of Indigenous Peoples and Traditional Communities
Reading time 4 min of reading Comments 0 comments

UN Issues Urgent Warning: New Brazilian Law Could Accelerate Amazon Devastation and Ignore Rights of Indigenous Peoples and Traditional Communities

Written by Noel Budeguer
Published on 01/08/2025 at 12:21
Be the first to react!
React to this article

President Lula Has Days to Decide: Sign or Veto the Law That Could Transform the Future of the Amazon and Brazil’s Image in the World

On the eve of COP30, Brazil faces an environmental dilemma that could compromise its international image. A new bill regarding environmental licensing, approved by the National Congress, awaits the final decision of President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, who must either sign or veto it by August 8. According to experts, if approved as it is, the text will represent a serious setback in environmental protection policies and may pave the way for the deforestation of millions of hectares of forest.

The UN Special Rapporteur for Human Rights and the Environment, Astrid Puentes Riaño, has harshly criticized the proposal. In an interview with BBC News, she described the proposal as a “decades-long setback” and warned of the risks of irreversible damage to the Amazon and other areas of great environmental importance. “Without proper analysis, changes or the continuation of projects can represent deforestation in the Amazon,” she stated.

Minister Marina Silva indicated that President Lula may veto some parts of the new environmental licensing project

18 Million Hectares Under Threat

Based on data from the Socioenvironmental Institute (ISA), Astrid estimates that the new legislation could withdraw protection from around 18 million hectares, an area equivalent to the entire territory of Uruguay. The concern is that by relaxing licensing rules, the project will facilitate the expansion of activities such as mining and agriculture — including in areas currently protected by law.

Among the most controversial points is the possibility of automatic licensing. Under the new rule, environmental agencies would have up to 12 months (extendable for another 12) to respond to a project. If the deadline expires without a response, the license could be granted automatically. Experts believe this could allow high-impact enterprises to proceed without the necessary technical or scientific rigor.

Less Consultation and Less Control

Another aspect that raises the alarm is the reduction in the requirement for consultations with indigenous and quilombola communities. Under the proposal, only groups directly affected must be consulted. According to the UN, this represents a threat to local communities’ participation in decisions that could severely affect their ways of life and ancestral territories.

Astrid Puentes also highlights that the project favors self-declaration of environmental impact by small-scale agricultural enterprises, through simple online forms. This could weaken oversight, especially in regions where illegal deforestation is already a constant reality.

“Mining or infrastructure projects cannot be authorized without a complete analysis of environmental impacts. The current proposal opens dangerous loopholes in this regard,” says the UN rapporteur.

Area of the Amazon devastated by fires and deforestation: a scenario like this could become even more common with the approval of the new environmental licensing law, which allows for automatic license granting and reduces oversight and consultation requirements for indigenous communities, according to UN warnings.

Deforestation on the Rise and Extreme Drought

The alert comes at a critical moment. In recent months, satellite monitoring data has confirmed high deforestation rates in the Amazon, with extensive areas consumed by fires exacerbated by the historic drought of 2024. The combination of forest destruction and water scarcity is already directly affecting the health of the local population and global climate balance.

Civil society entities, such as the Climate Observatory, indicate that the text of the new licensing project primarily serves the interests of sectors of agribusiness and mining, which have long pressured for a streamlining of environmental processes.

Meanwhile, proponents of the project argue that the law will “modernize” the current system, which is considered slow and inefficient. According to this view, the new model would allow greater agility for enterprises deemed strategic, such as roads, power plants, and energy facilities.

Divided Government and International Pressure

Within the government, the issue divides opinions. Environment Minister Marina Silva has publicly opposed various points of the project and stated that if the law is signed without changes, it could be challenged in the Supreme Court (STF).

At an event in Brasília, Marina stated that the government is considering a possible partial veto and the creation of a more balanced legislative alternative. “It’s not enough to veto. It’s necessary to veto and have something to put in its place,” said the minister. The idea would be to preserve valid technical points of the proposal while also preventing the advancement of norms that endanger the forest and human rights.

The final decision from Lula comes at a delicate context. Brazil will host the COP30, the United Nations Climate Conference, in November, in Belém (PA). The sanctioning of a law that weakens environmental protection mechanisms could generate international criticism and undermine the climate leadership that the country has been trying to consolidate in recent years.

If the president vetoes the project, Congress could still overturn the veto and maintain the original text. The dispute, therefore, is far from over.

Sign up
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
most recent
older Most voted
Built-in feedback
View all comments
Noel Budeguer

I am an Argentine journalist based in Rio de Janeiro, focusing on energy and geopolitics, as well as technology and military affairs. I produce analyses and reports with accessible language, data, context, and strategic insight into the developments impacting Brazil and the world. 📩 Contact: noelbudeguer@gmail.com

Share in apps
0
I'd love to hear your opinion, please comment.x