Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
6 min of reading 
0 comments 
A 900 kg lid disappeared during the Pascal-B nuclear test in Nevada on August 27, 1957, and Los Alamos Laboratory physicist Brownlee calculated a speed of 66 km/s, six times Earth’s escape velocity, but believes the lid vaporized due to friction before reaching space.
On August 27, 1957, two months before the launch of the Soviet Sputnik, a 900-kilogram steel lid disappeared from the mouth of a well in the middle of the Nevada desert, thrown upwards by a 300-ton TNT nuclear explosion detonated 152 meters deep. Physicist Robert Brownlee, an astrophysicist at Los Alamos National Laboratory and responsible for the underground nuclear test known as Pascal-B, had positioned a high-speed camera pointed at the mouth of the well, recording 1,000 frames per second, and when the film was developed, the lid appeared in only one frame, partially visible, before completely disappearing from the frame, never to be found again. Brownlee calculated that the lid’s speed at the well’s exit reached up to 66 kilometers per second, or about 240,000 kilometers per hour, a speed six times greater than that required to escape Earth’s gravity, a number that has fueled one of the most discussed curiosities in Cold War history for almost 70 years: could that lid have become the first human object to reach space?
The answer from the scientist who made the calculation himself is less romantic than the legend suggests. “I have no idea what happened to the lid, but I always assumed it was probably vaporized before reaching space,” Brownlee stated in an interview reproduced by scientific and military history publications. Updated calculations in 2019 reinforce the vaporization hypothesis: the lid’s un-aerodynamic shape would have generated such intense compression and friction with the atmosphere that the steel piece likely disintegrated in the first seconds after exiting the well, before reaching sufficient altitude to escape the layer of air surrounding the planet. The story is real, the numbers are verifiable, but the most probable conclusion is that the lid turned into vapor, not a satellite.
What was Operation Plumbbob and how did the lid enter history
The test that launched the lid was part of a much larger American nuclear development program. Operation Plumbbob was a series of 29 nuclear tests conducted between May and October 1957 at the Nevada Test Site, involving 21 laboratories and government agencies and approximately 18,000 US Armed Forces personnel in Desert Rock VII and VIII exercises, with the objective of developing warheads for intercontinental missiles, air defenses, and anti-submarine weapons. The operation was not secret: it was disclosed to the press, included military observers of various nationalities, and had its names officially published by the United States Atomic Energy Commission, although technical details of yields and calculations were classified.
-
Soviet jet Yakovlev Yak-40 that was donated to USP has been completely abandoned for about 20 years and even has a bird’s nest in it.
-
It’s not just in Brazil: a multi-million dollar roundabout in the middle of nowhere exposes the scandal of broken promises in Hungary and becomes a symbol of expensive public works that lead absolutely nowhere.
-
Australian cattle ranchers face Glencore’s project that wanted to store liquid carbon underground and prevent the advance of a plan seen as a threat to the aquifer that sustains the interior.
-
The nuclear aircraft carrier USS Nimitz, 332 meters long and 100,000 tons, arrives in Rio de Janeiro on May 7 for its last operational voyage before deactivation, with joint exercises with the Brazilian Navy until May 14.
Pascal-B was the second underground nuclear test in American history and originated from a surprise that occurred a month earlier. On July 26, 1957, the Pascal-A test, the first US underground experiment, generated a yield of about 55 tons of TNT, 50,000 times greater than expected, and the lid covering that well was thrown while a jet of fire rose hundreds of meters into the Nevada night sky, a result that piqued Brownlee’s scientific curiosity about the mechanics of lids under nuclear pressure. For Pascal-B, a month later, Brownlee decided to film what happened to the lid at the mouth of the well, a decision that would produce one of the most commented records in the history of experimental physics.
How the 900 kg lid was launched by the Pascal-B nuclear test
The Pascal-B experiment setup transformed the test well into a gigantic cannon pointed at the sky. The 300-ton TNT nuclear bomb was buried 152 meters deep, with a 2-ton concrete plug over it to direct the explosion’s energy upwards through the cylindrical well, and at the mouth of the well, a 900-kilogram, approximately 10-centimeter-thick steel plate was welded, which would act as a seal until the moment of detonation. Brownlee positioned the high-speed camera pointed at the mouth of the well, not at the explosion itself (which occurred 152 meters below ground), recording 1,000 frames per second to capture the instant the plate would be ejected by the pressure of the nuclear detonation gases.
The result exceeded all predictions. At 10:35 PM on August 27, 1957, the bomb detonated, and when the camera film was developed, the plate appeared in a single frame, partially visible and already in upward motion, disappearing completely from the frame in the next shot, meaning that in less than a millisecond, the 900 kg plate accelerated from zero to a speed Brownlee calculated to be up to 66 kilometers per second. The Institute of Physics in the United Kingdom documents the calculation and confirms that the estimated speed is six times Earth’s escape velocity (approximately 11.2 km/s), a number that led Brownlee to comment that the plate shot out “like a bat out of hell” and fueled speculation that it might have preceded Sputnik into space.
Why most physicists believe the plate did not reach space
Despite the impressive numbers, the arguments against the hypothesis that the plate reached space are solid and come from the very scientist who conducted the experiment. Brownlee stated that he always presumed vaporization, and updated calculations in 2019 reinforce this conclusion: a poorly aerodynamic steel object traveling through the atmosphere at 66 km/s would generate such extreme compression and friction that the plate’s temperature would exceed steel’s melting point in fractions of a second, disintegrating it long before it reached an altitude where the atmosphere becomes thin enough for the effect to cease. Contemporary physicists argue that the plate would have decelerated below escape velocity before leaving the atmosphere, making its arrival in space physically improbable even if it hadn’t been completely vaporized.
On the opposite side of the discussion are the arguments that keep the speculation alive. The plate was never found on Earth, and some calculations suggest that given its mass and initial velocity, the object would not have had time to be completely destroyed before leaving the atmosphere, a scenario that would leave it traveling on an interplanetary trajectory through space, not in a stable orbit like Sputnik, but on a silent course into the void between planets. The conceptual difference is important: Sputnik, launched on October 4, 1957, 38 days after Pascal-B, entered a controlled orbit around Earth, while the plate, even if it had reached space, would have continued in a straight line with no possibility of return, a distinction that separates satellite from projectile and prevents any real equivalence between the two events.
What the case of the plate meant for nuclear and space science
The Pascal-B plate incident was not limited to the category of curiosity: it had real consequences for science. The Pascal series contributed to the development of safe underground nuclear tests, a standard that would become mandatory after the Partial Nuclear Test Ban Treaty of 1963, which banned explosions in the atmosphere, in space, and underwater, and the concept of using nuclear explosions for object propulsion inspired Project Orion in the 1950s and 1960s, which studied the possibility of propelling spacecraft through small, successive nuclear detonations. Project Orion never got off the ground precisely because of the 1963 treaty, but its principles continue to be discussed in theoretical interplanetary propulsion proposals that NASA and space agencies periodically revisit.
The story of the plate entered scientific pop culture and continues to generate debate almost 70 years later. There might exist, somewhere in interplanetary space, a metal plate traveling silently since 1957, or it might have dissolved into steel vapor in the first seconds after the explosion, and the truth is, no one knows for sure. It is precisely the lack of a definitive answer that keeps the case alive: improbable that it reached space, yes, but technically impossible to completely rule out, a combination that makes the Pascal-B plate one of the most sought-after and never-found objects in the history of physics.
And you, do you think the plate reached space or vaporized in the atmosphere? Leave your opinion in the comments.
Be the first to react!