Portuguese 
English 
Spanish 
3 min of reading 
0 comments 
For Paulo Guedes, High Interest Rates Are Not “The Fault of the Central Bank”: They Are Directly Reflected in the Excessive Government Spending and This Harms Companies “In Full Flight”.
The economist Paulo Guedes, former Minister of Economy, has once again criticized the Brazilian fiscal model and pointed to public spending as the main reason for high interest rates in the country. In a recent interview, he explained that the Central Bank merely reacts to the imbalance in government accounts, keeping interest rates high to contain inflation. For Guedes, “high interest rates do not arise from the BC, they arise from excessive government spending”, and this model ultimately harms companies of all sizes.
He also recalled the hyperinflation that reached 5,000% in the 1980s and early 1990s, highlighting that Brazil only overcame instability with the Real Plan but remained trapped in a scenario of structurally high interest rates and weak growth.
What Paulo Guedes Points Out as the Origin of the Problem
According to Paulo Guedes, the recurrent fiscal imbalance forces the Central Bank to keep interest rates at high levels to contain pressure on prices. If the government spends too much, the BC reacts with high interest rates; if it spends less, interest rates may fall.
-
Lock manufacturer from Rio Grande do Sul invests R$ 150 million to surpass R$ 1 billion in revenue, create 200 jobs, and double storage capacity, while choosing Santa Catarina to set up a new logistics center and speed up deliveries in Southern Brazil.
-
Neymar elevates the status of the Northeast with a billion-dollar megaproject of 28 luxury developments, 100 km of turquoise-blue beaches, 10 residential projects already under construction, multimillion-dollar beachfront mansions, an exclusive sports arena, and an expected impressive movement of R$ 7.5 billion in Pernambuco and Alagoas.
-
Luciano Hang’s cousin left Havan after nearly a decade, invested in real estate, and now manages R$ 6 billion in launches; the entrepreneur, who only gets paid when he sells, claims to have sold out an entire building in Santa Catarina in just 45 minutes.
-
Trump threatens Brazil with a 25% tariff and uses illegal deforestation as an argument to pressure exports; US report accuses environmental failures, while recent decline in the Amazon exposes a dispute that could impact Brazilian trade and politics.
In practice, this stifles economic growth. Large, medium, and small companies, which rely on credit to invest, end up being “mortally wounded” by high interest rates, which make financing more expensive and reduce the capacity for expansion.
The Reminder of Hyperinflation
During the interview, Paulo Guedes recalled the period of hyperinflation, when measures such as price freezes (Cruzado Plan) and asset blocking (Collor government) did not solve the root of the problem. According to him, the country only stabilized the currency with the Real Plan but remained trapped in the dilemma: traded inflation for indebtedness, accumulating a “snowball” of interest and low growth.
He also remembered the use of “overnight” — very short-term financial investments that families used to protect savings amid rampant price controls. This behavior marked an entire generation and shaped Brazilian financial culture.
High Taxes and Centralized State
Another central point of Paulo Guedes‘ speech was the comparison of the Brazilian tax burden with that of other emerging countries. While the international average is around 25% to 26% of GDP, in Brazil this number reaches 34% or 35%.
For Guedes, this difference shows a heavy State, concentrated in Brasília, but absent “on the ground”, that is, in essential areas like health, education, security, and sanitation. His motto, “more Brazil, less Brasília,” summarizes the defense for decentralizing resources and fiscal discipline.
What He Advocates as a Solution
In Paulo Guedes‘ view, the only way to sustainably reduce interest rates is to control public spending. Without that, Brazil will remain trapped in a vicious cycle: high spending → high interest rates → expensive credit → harmed companies → less investment and employment.
For the former minister, a consistent fiscal adjustment is the key to freeing up growth and allowing for lower interest rates in a sustainable manner. He also emphasizes that structural reforms are necessary to prioritize investments in areas that truly impact the lives of the population.
Paulo Guedes‘ remarks expose the debate over the weight of the State in the economy and how this directly affects the lives of Brazilians. For him, as long as the government spends more than it collects, interest rates will remain high and the country will continue to be limited in growth.
And you, do you agree with Paulo Guedes’ view? Do you think the problem in Brazil lies in public spending or elsewhere? Leave your opinion in the comments — we want to hear from those who experience this firsthand.
-
-
-
3 people reacted to this.