A Bill That Aims to Set ICMS in the Country Is Quite Controversial and Has Been Generating a Lot of Debates. The CNM Highlights the Risk of Municipalities Losing Revenues If Approved
Last Thursday, Arthur Lira, the President of the Chamber of Deputies, stated that he would put to vote on next Tuesday, the 24th, the bill that classifies fuels, electricity, telecommunications, and transportation as essential goods and services. This means that the ICMS rate will be capped at 17%.
Even with Brazil suffering greatly from the prices of fuels and electricity bills, the measure aimed at limiting ICMS is quite controversial, generating many debates on the topic in recent weeks.

The CNM (National Confederation of Municipalities) released a note strongly criticizing the bill. The official note criticizes and warns about the consequences of a potential approval of the project. According to the entity, if approved, the project could cause a loss of 15 billion to municipalities.
-
For the economist José Kobori, the USA gained a trump card to “blackmail” Brazil and undermine China’s influence by classifying the PCC and Comando Vermelho as terrorists, increasing the power to pressure companies, banks, and even Pix.
-
The labor shortage has changed its face in Brazil: companies hire 80% more, but workers stay only 6.8 months in the job, the service market becomes a “revolving door,” and businesses spend increasingly more to train teams that soon leave.
-
Chinese giant chooses SC to set up its first factory in Brazil, investing R$ 250 million and producing MRI machines costing R$ 10 million each, with 100 direct jobs and 5% of revenue allocated to research.
-
After selling a unit for R$ 115 million to pay off debts, a traditional factory in SC founded in 1932 has a new R$ 64.8 million plan denied by the court and retains about 690 workers in Joinville.
“The change of category represents an incentive for the consumption of non-renewable energies while significantly impacting the main tax collected in Brazil, reducing the scope of executing public policies. In the last 12 months, the total ICMS collection exceeded R$ 673 billion, of which R$ 168 billion was transferred to municipalities via their share,” the note highlights.
Limiting ICMS Is Not the Only Alternative
Paulo Ziulkoski, President of the CNM, admitted that the ICMS rate charged to Brazilians is indeed high; however, there are other solutions with less impact than approving the bill.
“There are other solutions that can be adopted by the authorities and the National Congress, as this project proposes once again to take resources away from States and Municipalities, significantly harming the provision of services to the population… It is argued that instead of this measure, there should be an increase in taxes on oil companies, which today are the ones making the highest profits and can bear these costs for the benefit of our society,” he said.
Understand All the Controversy Surrounding ICMS
The STF, Federal Supreme Court, decided last year that any ICMS charge above 17% on the supply of electricity and telecommunications services is unconstitutional. Even after the Supreme Court’s decision, data from Aneel (National Electric Energy Agency) shows that, on average, 21.3% of the electricity bill is represented by ICMS.
The high price of fuels is one of the main reasons for high inflation in the country. Due to the price of oil in the international market and rising inflation, this number has been continuously increasing in recent months.

Be the first to react!