Before Getting Married, Charles Darwin Made a Meticulous List of Pros and Cons — and Almost Gave Up the Idea
In 1838, Charles Darwin was going through an intense phase of his life. At 29, he had already completed his journey around the world aboard the HMS Beagle and was accumulating notes that would form the basis of the theory of natural selection. But in the midst of this crucial moment in science, another question occupied his mind: Was it worth getting married?
Darwin viewed this decision as an experiment. He did not make a hasty decision. He took pencil and paper and began to list, frankly and logically, the pros and cons of marriage. All in a methodical way. As if it were part of his scientific work.
The Benefits of Getting Married, According to Darwin
In July of that year, he wrote the list “If I Marry.” Among the benefits he saw were:
-
The United States, China, and the Emirates are funding a race for solar satellites capable of capturing light 24 hours a day in space and sending energy back to Earth via microwave beams.
-
Scientists discover “chemical fingerprint” that could help reveal extraterrestrial life without finding microbes or fossils, just by analyzing hidden patterns in amino acids and fatty acids from Mars, icy moons, and meteorites.
-
Reaching Mach 2.25 in supersonic flight and carrying 9 tons of weapons on 13 hardpoints, the Eurofighter Typhoon has become the European fighter jet that combines brutal speed, advanced radar, and extreme agility to dominate the skies.
-
The great Atlantic current will lose 51% of its strength by the end of the century even if all countries meet their emission targets, and the reduction of this ocean circulation that balances the global climate could affect Brazilian biomes such as the Amazon and the Caatinga by altering rainfall and temperature patterns.
- Having children, “God willing”
- Having a constant companion and a friend in old age
- Someone to love and play with — which, according to him, was “better than a dog”
- Having a home and someone to take care of the house
- Enjoying music and female conversations
Despite this, he expressed discomfort. To him, these good things could also be “a terrible waste of time.” In another section, he vented:
“My God, it’s intolerable to think of spending my whole life as a castrated bee, working, working, and, in the end, nothing. No, I won’t do that.”
But he soon contradicted himself with another mental image: “Imagine living all day alone in a dirty house in London. Imagine a kind and gentle wife on a sofa, with a good fireplace, books, and music, perhaps.”
The Long List of Drawbacks
Next, Darwin listed the cons of marriage. And they were more numerous:
- Loss of freedom to go wherever he wanted
- Having to choose when to socialize
- Missing out on conversations with intelligent men in clubs
- Having to visit relatives and fulfill social formalities
- Concerns about children, arguments, and expenses
- Wasted time
- Not being able to read at night anymore
- Risk of gaining weight and becoming idle
- More responsibilities
- Less money for books
- Obligations to work even harder if he had many children
- The chance that his wife would not like London and he would end up exiled and degraded
Even with the balance seemingly tipping to the negative side, Darwin wrote at the end of the list:
“Marry Q.E.D.”
The Latin abbreviation means “as it has been demonstrated.”
Uncertainties Until the End
Even after writing that marriage was necessary, Darwin was not completely decided. He continued reflecting. He even wrote doubts about the ideal timing for it: “Having demonstrated that it is necessary to marry, when? Soon or later?”
He had received advice saying that marrying early was better, as feelings were still alive and character more moldable. But that frightened him. He listed more concerns, among them:
- Endless problems and expenses
- Arguments caused by social obligations
- Daily waste of time
- Never learning French
- Never seeing the continent
- Never flying in a balloon
- Never traveling alone to Wales
The doubt was intense. At times, he saw himself as a future “sad slave.” At others, he sought to cheer himself up with encouraging phrases: “Cheer up. You cannot live this solitary life, with a numbed old age, without friends, cold and childless.”
In the end, he accepted his fate with resignation: “Don’t worry, trust chance. There are many happy slaves.”
The Decision Was Made
Shortly after this long journey of reflection, Darwin made his decision. On November 11, 1838, he wrote in his diary: “The Day of Days!”
Emma Wedgwood, his cousin, had accepted his marriage proposal.
Thus, the man who dedicated his life to understanding the evolution of species also went through the most common dilemma of human existence. Among so many notes and reasoning, Darwin chose marriage. He chose love.
With information from CNN.

Be the first to react!